¿ìè¶ÌÊÓÆµ

This Week’s Letters

On the many marvels of the human brain (2)

In my experience of memory retention, it seems that, at the time this occurs, the brain – consciously or unconsciously – places a memory into a category with a rating of importance varying from “retention essential” to “almost discardable”. Memories in the top category can be retained almost indefinitely, while those in the lowest, although probably not completely lost, need considerable stimulation to be retrieved (24 February, p 32).

However, the brain may rejig the category of memories. After a critical exam, for example, the memory of material in a subject of no further interest or importance will inevitably be relegated. Arguably, memory can therefore be enhanced by consciously assessing that some information or particular experience is important, so must be retained.

On the many marvels of the human brain (1)

If thinking hard doesn’t cause the brain to consume more energy, it doesn’t make evolutionary sense that stress hormone levels rise when we need to concentrate. It is well known that elite chess players lose weight during tournaments. Even though the brain is only responsible for a small percentage of the extra calories burned, its extra energy requirement leads to stress that makes us burn more calories and feel exhausted.

On the many marvels of the human brain (3)

Jeffrey Lapides has discovered microbes in the brain seemingly implicated in Alzheimer’s disease, an unexpected finding. Will this, and similar discoveries, signal a rethink about neurological and mental illnesses? Suspicions must arise that, overall, this may not be a benign microbiome, especially if pathogens are entering the brain.

We have medicines that act on some of these illnesses, so the question is whether current drugs are primarily acting on a microbial population and not necessarily on neural tissue or the psyche.

The real question is why aren't we all cannibals?

Your look at cannibalism mentioned that over the course of history, the practice “has been surprisingly common”. In fact, this shouldn’t be surprising at all. Cannibalism solves the food shortage problem and is environmentally friendly. So why not?

The real question should be: why did cannibalism all but vanish from the culture of Homo sapiens? Perhaps it was due to worries about being on the receiving end, which would make early society unstable, or the evolution of empathy (17 February, p 32).

More views on the ultra-processed food debate (1)

Meat is the most “ultra-processed food”. It is ultimately plants that have been chewed, digested, broken down, chemically altered, restructured as animal flesh, slaughtered, skinned, butchered and processed even further. Any factory processing of plant-based foods pales in comparison (24 February, p 21).

More views on the ultra-processed food debate (2)

Dismissing concerns over ultra-processed food isn’t so simple. We can’t rely on cravings and appetite for health if we eat stuff that tells our body, by flavour and texture, that it has one nutritional profile while delivering an utterly different one. And what about the removal of essential and beneficial micronutrients when, for example, maize and palm oil are refined to sufficient blandness to be a bulk ingredient in everything from cake to low-fat mayonnaise? Also note today’s dire health trends, not just in adults but children too. Surely our food is suspect and demands wider investigation?

Possible evolutionary origins of ADHD

The gains from flitting between foraged food sources may not have promoted what we call ADHD. Instead, look at birds feeding on the ground. They don’t hang around to pick up the food for a long time, but make frequent, random movements away to different places. This makes it harder for a stealthy predator to pounce accurately. A hominid carefully picking all the berries in a bush would be in danger (2 March, p 9).

Calling all members of the 100-kilometre-high club

James Dinneen’s review of A City On Mars was interesting. As its authors say, there has been, to our knowledge, no documented human sexual activity in space. However, given our species’ predilections, I would be surprised if, with the person-hours racked up on past and present space stations, not to mention lunar and other orbital sojourns, nobody has experience of sex in space (24 February, p 29).

Tweak my dreams to stop leg ache please

Here is a commercial application of dream engineering that I would welcome. Many people experience leg cramps at night, incidents where, in the middle of sleep, your leg turns into stone. It is very painful. Dream engineering might be able to implant the suggestion that our legs should remain relaxed during sleep. People would pay good money for this (17 February, p 36).

It may be a stretch to find evidence for string theory

To find evidence to back string theory, Joseph Conlon suggests looking for certain primordial gravitational waves from very early in the universe. Presumably, these would be stretched as the universe expands, just as light waves are. Radiation we see as the cosmic microwave background was . Gravitational waves from before the CMB would be stretched (and weakened) even more (17 February, p 40). Would they still be detectable?

Wishing for aviation's green revolution

I read your story on making jet fuel from carbon dioxide and it struck me that for this to succeed commercially, all it needs is a place that can generate lots of clean energy, has capital to invest in the infrastructure and has a need to replace an oil-dependent economy. I hope it really is that simple (24 February, p 12).