David Hone, Author at żěè¶ĚĘÓƵ Science news and science articles from żěè¶ĚĘÓƵ Thu, 14 Dec 2023 15:12:58 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.0.1 242057827 The best science fiction movies about dinosaurs, by a palaeontologist /article/2387674-the-best-science-fiction-movies-about-dinosaurs-by-a-palaeontologist/?utm_campaign=RSS|NSNS&utm_content=currents&utm_medium=RSS&utm_source=NSNS Tue, 22 Aug 2023 10:22:46 +0000 /?post_type=article&p=2387674 Baby Triceratops in Walking with Dinosaurs
“One of the best renditions of dinosaurs on film in decades”: Baby Triceratops in Walking with Dinosaurs.
Alamy Stock Photo

I’m a specialising in the behaviour and ecology of dinosaurs, but I also write about them. My new book, , looks at the current gaps in our knowledge and understanding of these amazing ancient animals. But for all that we still don’t know, dinosaurs remain an enduring subject for film-makers and have now been on screen for more than a century with varying degrees of accuracy and interest. I’ve tried to get in a real mix of genres and approaches here and to consider these films as products of their time, since many were excellent when first made.

A still from The Lost World.
A still from The Lost World.
Alamy Stock Photo

(1925).

One of the first ever cinema outings for dinosaurs, this silent era adaptation of has some remarkably good animation for its time. The dinosaurs are not only nicely made and animated, but show realistic and interesting behaviours not often seen in other movies – for example, a parent triceratops is shown looking after a youngster. These dinosaurs are shown as animals to be studied and enjoyed, rather than monsters that are just there to harass the protagonists.

(1933).

A true classic, and while the eponymous giant ape may be the star, the dinosaurs play a prominent role. Inevitably, we see a very much herbivorous sauropod desperate to chow down on a sailor, setting the tone for many future dinosaurs in movies, but the stegosaurus with its period-correct four pairs of tail spikes and the wonderfully animated tyrannosaurus are both great. Hollywood legend has it that one of the background plates for this film was reused in Citizen Kane, so arguably the greatest film ever has some pterosaurs flying in it. Also, an honourable mention to the , which retained a 1930s-era aesthetic for the dinosaurs, but also really thought about how they might have evolved and survived post the end-Cretaceous extinction.

(1966).

It’s probably fair to say that accuracy wasn’t a priority here, with “cavemen” (from as recently as 10,000 years ago) mingled with a range of prehistoric animals (from 150 million to 65 million years ago), but the dinosaurs and other animals animated by stop-motion legend Ray Harryhausen are a delight. The young allosaurus in particular is an all tail-swishing, fast-running menace, and the triceratops would have graced any museum at the time as a model of what researchers thought dinosaurs looked like. The oversized, bat-like winged pterosaurs are rather less good, if still well animated.

(1969).

An even better Harryhausen dinosaur movie, though a much less well known one. This features a “lost valley” of dinosaurs uncovered in Mexico by a circus owner, which leads to the fantastic spectacle of the titular carnivore fighting an elephant after the local cowboys have thrown lassos over a centrosaurus. Gwangi might be a made-up dinosaur, but it and the other prehistoric creatures are beautifully rendered and, as with The Lost World, they aren’t just there to provide menace.

A scene from The Valley of Gwangi.
A scene from The Valley of Gwangi.
Alamy Stock Photo

(1977).

Another little-known entry, and one of the last stop-motion classics. All of the money in this schlocky B-movie about a spaceship crash-landing on a dinosaur-ridden planet went on the effects (at the expense of sets, props, the script and the actors), but it was well spent. The animals are wonderfully rendered and beautifully animated, and a fair number of lesser-known species get some good airtime – even if the main “villain” is inevitably a tyrannosaurus.

A scene from Planet of the Dinosaurs.
A scene from Planet of the Dinosaurs.
Alamy Stock Photo

(2001).

This is probably my favourite of the series. The CGI used to create the dinosaurs and the quality of the animatronics were at their best. This, coupled with a decent story, tight running time and the least amount of children in any of the movies means it is a great entry. The fact it brought spinosaurus to the world’s attention is of questionable value, although it gets definite bonus points for the really nice pteranodon (even if they have teeth and aren’t dinosaurs).

Sam Neill in Jurassic Park III.
Sam Neill in Jurassic Park III.
Alamy Stock Photo

(2007).

This is one of a huge raft of relatively recent made-for-TV movies that used the increasing accessibility of CGI and dinosaur popularity to churn something out. However, it is a rough diamond, and with a bit more of a budget, it could have been great. In 1521, a troop of lost conquistadores in Mexico discover that the local Aztecs have a late surviving tyrannosaurus running around in the jungle. It contains a far better digital model than turns up in even big-budget films and has a nice and creepy Jaws-like feel.

(2012).

The odd history of this movie (compiled from a multi-part television series that veered from detailed documentary to classic cartoon-inspired parodies) means it is more than a bit hit and miss. But the hits are top class and the wordless storytelling, plus scenes directly inspired by genuine palaeontological discoveries and scientific papers, make this a worthwhile entry. Plus, it’s narrated by Werner Herzog!

(2013).

No, not the classic 90s TV series, but a whole movie of the same name. The dinosaurs might talk to one another, but enormous detail has gone into the models, and the creation of an entire ecosystem full of species that are rarely, if ever, shown on screen means this one of the best renditions of dinosaurs on film in decades. The work of consultant palaeontologists shines here as it so rarely does in many other big-screen dinosaurs.

(2014).

Another little-known effort, this Australian fantasy movie is aimed squarely at children, but it has some of the best rendered dinosaurs shown for many a year. Some incredible-looking creatures make it to screen; this shows what can be done with a limited budget but a great eye for anatomy and modern research.

A dishonourable mention goes to (2023), the most recent of the Hollywood efforts to fall horribly flat, thanks to a bunch of dinosaurs that are recognisable species but shown in weird and outdated ways, making them neither creative new monsters nor modern renditions of real animals. These come alongside some genuinely novel creations, which then begs the question: why set the story on Earth if you are going to have fictional creatures? In short: bad dinosaurs, bad film.

]]>
2387674
There are things we will never know about dinosaurs – here’s why /article/2315854-there-are-things-we-will-never-know-about-dinosaurs-heres-why/?utm_campaign=RSS|NSNS&utm_content=currents&utm_medium=RSS&utm_source=NSNS Wed, 13 Apr 2022 18:00:00 +0000 http://mg25433822.800 THE study of dinosaurs has made some amazing strides in the past 20 years. The discovery of numerous fully feathered dinosaurs offers incontrovertible evidence of the evolution of birds from their non-flying ancestors, for instance. We also have fossils that preserve ancient patterns of these long-extinct animals. Around 50 new dinosaur species have been named every year of the past two decades. New studies have appeared on dinosaur behaviour, ecology, sex, physiology, brain structure, hearing and many more features besides. It is truly a treasure trove of data, and new avenues of research keep producing ever more interesting and surprising insights into these animals. And yet, rather inevitably, the fossil record is incredibly incomplete. For all the progress that has been made in two centuries of studying dinosaurs, there are still innumerable things that we don’t know about them. We may have some ideas about the colours of a few dinosaurs, but these are only a handful of individuals that may not even be that representative of their species, let alone any others. We have done detailed studies of how Tyrannosaurus rex could stand, walk, run and turn, but there is nothing like this even for the other 30 species of tyrannosaurs, let alone other groups. Those gaps may at least be filled with new finds one day, but what about the things we might never know? Think about some of the strangest animals out there, those that are most unlike their near relatives or are hold-outs of some long-lost group. Giant tortoises, marine iguanas and flightless cormorants on the Galapagos Islands; kiwis, kakapo and tuatara in New Zealand; the (now sadly extinct) rails of Hawaii; lemurs and extinct elephant birds on Madagascar; and so on. What they have in common is where they live – islands, usually ones that are both volcanic and a long way from any other land masses, and they are often tropical too. These are places where isolated populations can cling on and take interesting turns, as small groups evolve under unusual conditions. They are often free from some of the constraints that come from the presence of competitors and predators, which can allow them to flourish where elsewhere they have perished, or to diversify and produce new and unusual forms. The thing is, though, such environments are terrible for forming fossils. Small bits of land are likely to have limited numbers of large rivers and lakes with lots of silt to bury animals. Tropical environments have very high rates of decay, so dead bodies often don’t last long enough to be buried. Volcanic islands can easily sink into the sea and be at the mercy of tectonic activities, and such places are generally very unlikely to be exposed on the surface where paleontologists can pick at them 100 million years later. In short, however bizarre we consider dinosaurs to be now, they almost certainly produced far more interesting and unusual animals on all manner of islands in the Mesozoic Era (around 252 million to 66 million years ago), but it is incredibly unlikely that we will ever find them. Either the fossils never formed or those islands have been destroyed and are now inaccessible. Our knowledge of the evolution of animals on islands is enough to give us confidence that strange dinosaurs appeared in these places, though similarly, our understanding of the processes of fossilisation tells us that we are unlikely to access the fossils in the future, however much we dig. We have learned so much about dinosaurs, and there is still so much more to come. But there are fascinating gaps we might never fill, with only tantalising hints about these wondrous ancient creatures. David Hone is the author of The Future of Dinosaurs (Hodder & Stoughton).]]> 2315854