
Coral reefs may be more capable of adapting to hotter and more acidic oceans than we thought, raising hopes that efforts to slash our greenhouse gas emissions and restore reefs stand a chance of preserving these biodiverse ecosystems.
âThese results provide us with a possible pathway forward, but it depends entirely on what we decide to do about climate change and what we decide to do about local stressors,â says at the University of Hawaiâi at MÄnoa.
Rising levels of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere due to our emissions pose a twin threat to the worldâs coral reefs. Higher temperatures stress corals and this can lead to mass bleaching and death. In addition, atmospheric CO2 is absorbed by the ocean, making the water more acidic and weakening coral skeletons. This, along with pollution and overfishing, has already created a crisis for the planetâs reefs, with extreme heat over the past two years spurring mass bleaching events around the world.
Advertisement
Current models of how reefs will respond to further climate change project an even grimmer future. âAlmost all warm-water coral reefs are projected to suffer significant losses of area and local extinctions, even if global warming is limited to 1.5ÂșC,â according to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, a prediction it labels a âhigh confidenceâ one.
However, these models may not capture the extent and speed at which coral species could adapt, says Jury. âWe havenât had the data as to what is realistic.â
To find out more, Jury and his colleagues collected dozens of specimens of eight different coral species from reefs around Oâahu, Hawaiâi. They were then grown in an outdoor lab under four different conditions: under todayâs climate, one with temperatures raised by 2°C but water chemistry unchanged, another with temperatures held but water chemistry made more acidic, and the last with both temperature and water chemistry changed to produce the warmer, more acidic conditions expected in 2075 under a high-emission scenario. âWe hit them pretty hard,â says Jury.
The exposure lasted nearly six months, far longer than most coral stress tests, but âthe corals did surprisingly wellâ, says Jury. All saw lower growth rates â a measure of coral health â under the more stressful conditions. Yet individuals of all species survived the combined stressors, with no clear trade-off between tolerance to heat and acidity.
The researchers also compared genetic data of tolerant and more sensitive corals to estimate what proportion of these traits could be passed to future generations, finding between one-quarter and one-half of tolerance was heritable. Based on this, they estimate these coral species have the potential to adapt to between 1 and 1.7°C of warming over the next 50 years, a rate that would be in line with Paris Agreement emissions targets.

at Newcastle University, UK, who wasnât involved with the study, says this is in line with her teamâs modelling based on yet-to-be-published heat-stress experiments. âIf we do get to the targets, corals have a chance to survive. Which is great news,â she says. However, she says the small number of corals tested still leaves the true potential for adaptation uncertain. âDoing this type of analysis with corals is extremely challenging.â
Nonetheless, there is building evidence of a significant potential to adapt to changing oceans. For instance, in a second study published this month, at Southern Cross University in Australia and her colleagues analysed heat tolerance of a coral species on the Great Barrier Reef. They found unexpectedly large variation in heat tolerance, even among corals in the same part of the reef. This could be especially valuable for efforts to restore reefs by breeding more tolerant corals, says Naugle.
âIâm cautiously optimistic,â says at the University of Hawaiâi at MÄnoa, who wasnât involved with any of the research. But she cautions that any adaptive potential still depends on how much coral is left after extreme events. âIn a lot of areas around the world, thereâs little coral cover left.â
Proceedings of the Royal Society B
Communications Earth and Environment