èƵ

Best-case scenario for climate change is now 1.6°C of warming

The totemic climate goal of keeping warming below 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels is essentially impossible at this point
The sun is setting on 1.5°C
Taro Hama @ e-kamakura/Getty Images

Humanity’s goal of limiting global warming to 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels, which has been totemic in climate policy for the past decade, is now almost certainly out of reach. Limiting warming to 1.6°C has become the best-case scenario for climate action, with the hope of bringing temperatures back to 1.5°C later in the century using technology to remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere.

“1.5°C without overshoot is not attainable,” says at the Potsdam Institute for Climate Research in Germany. “You definitely therefore need to prepare for one tenth, or potentially multiple tenths of a degree, beyond that target.”

Bertram and his colleagues came to this conclusion by running a series of models that accounted for realistic constraints in rolling out green technologies and implementing climate policies, as well as “enabling factors”, such as reduction in energy demand.

Green technologies like renewable energy have taken off dramatically in recent years, but the key constraint to rapid climate action is the ability of governments to roll out carbon-limiting policies such as carbon taxes, the team found.

Some countries simply don’t have the infrastructure or the bureaucracy to effectively enforce policies like carbon pricing, says Bertram. “Even if we see a massive shift in the coming years politically, we still can’t get around these hard facts,” he says. “It takes regulation for some of these solutions and you can’t expect all countries to have perfect regulation.”

Once this is accounted for in modelling, the best-case scenario we can hope for is limiting peak warming to 1.6°C, says Bertram. Even that will require huge political will from higher-income countries that have the greatest hope of taking climate action, he says. “We are very far from that world, politically.”

In fact, the researchers say it is more likely than not that we won’t be able to limit warming to 1.6°C. There are a wide range of uncertainties, but they calculate the chance of succeeding at between 5 and 45 per cent. Success rates increase at 1.7°C, 1.8°C and so on. “The world needs to be prepared for the possibility of an overshoot of the 1.5°C limit by at least one and probably multiple tenths of a degree even under the highest possible ambition,” they write in their paper.

Team member at Imperial College London insists the paper shows “a relatively positive picture”. He points out that the models suggest warming can be held below 2°C assuming governments continue to improve their institutional capacities, and green technology can be rolled out rapidly. “Despite taking into account aspects of feasibility, [it shows] warming can be kept to relatively low levels,” he says.

This latest study reflects the growing scientific consensus that the 1.5°C temperature target, agreed by countries in Paris in 2015, is now unachievable without emissions overshoot. The last update from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) released in 2022 suggested a narrow path to limiting warming to 1.5°C was still possible, but since then global emissions have risen.

Human activities have already increased average global temperatures by 1.26°C above pre-industrial levels, with 2024 likely to be the first year that average temperatures surpass 1.5°C of warming.

at US non-profit Berkeley Earth says the paper “more or less states what has become a largely unspoken consensus in the community: that it’s too late to prevent warming from exceeding 1.5°C in the coming decades”.

But he stresses that warming below 2°C is still plausible. “While it might be too late to avoid passing 1.5°C in the coming decades, it’s not too late to limit warming to 1.6°C. The world does not end at 1.5°C, and every tenth of a degree matters in terms of the impacts to society, the natural world and future generations.”

at the University of Ottawa, Canada, says the work now shifts the focus of the debate to whether 1.6°C is achievable. “It puts that number 1.6°C out there. And that is what the debate is going to centre on now,” he says. “And after 1.6°C, if we surpass that, it’s going to be 1.7°C.”

Journal reference

Nature Climate Change

Topics: carbon emissions / greenhouse gas emissions