èƵ

Insomnia success suggests we need more nuanced mental health support

The standard "one-size-fits-all" approach to diagnosing and treating mental health problems is failing. Personalised treatments could make a big difference

2GRD8X5 High Angle View Of Text On White Background

THERE can be few things more debilitating than going to bed, after a long and tiring day, and being unable to drift off. The harder you try to fall asleep, the more difficult it becomes – a vicious cycle of unwanted wakefulness that takes a significant toll on the lives of millions.

But it doesn’t have to be this way, because a new, more nuanced understanding of insomnia has made it a solvable problem, as we report in our cover story. Underlying this improved understanding is the recognition that there isn’t one type of insomnia but many – a departure from the standard “one-size-fits-all” approach to the diagnosis and treatment of mental health problems, which is failing.

This recent progress on insomnia, built on identifying the different types and treating them accordingly, should be a flag-bearer for a new way to think about mental health problems more broadly.

Take depression. For decades, the go-to treatment strategy has been to prescribe drugs that boost levels of serotonin in the brain and yet, as a recent study found, low levels of this chemical messenger don’t appear to be the primary cause of the condition for most people. One person’s depression isn’t the same as another’s. Instead, we should identify the different types of depression, and the different causes, before considering treatments.

This approach – sometimes called precision psychiatry – isn’t entirely new, and it is fair to say that progress has been slower than many would have hoped. Studies performed to-date indicate there may be . And in the UK at least, there is a shortage of specialist mental health practitioners.

But that isn’t to say we should give up on the idea. In other areas of medicine, such as cancer, personalised treatments are beginning to be made available, and some of those taking them have seen spectacular improvements in their health. With mental health problems continuing to rise across the world, even limited success would be transformative.

Topics: Mental health / Sleep