èƵ

Antarctic bacteria reveal an evolutionary limit to dealing with heat

Some bacteria living in the Southern Ocean can't adapt to temperatures 2°C higher than what they can usually survive, and other organisms could face similar limits adapting to higher temperatures
Southern Ocean and Antarctic islands near the Antarctic Peninsula in winter; Shutterstock ID 204022084; purchase_order: -; job: -; client: -; other: -
Southern Ocean and Antarctic islands near the Antarctic Peninsula
Copyright (c) 2014 Tarpan/Shutterstock

A species of bacteria from the coastal waters of Antarctica is unable to evolve to tolerate temperatures much higher than it can currently survive. The finding suggests there is a hard limit to organisms’ ability to evolve adaptations to heat waves and long-term higher temperatures driven by climate change.

Bacteria are the Houdinis of evolution, escaping even the most challenging of environmental pressures. That is thanks to their sheer numbers and the fact that new generations grow so rapidly that they can quickly evolve adaptations. But they have their limits.

 at ETH Zurich in Switzerland and her colleagues subjected genetically homogeneous colonies of a marine bacterium called Pseudoalteromonas haloplanktis to gradually increasing heat, starting at 15°C and increasing to 30°C over 900 generations.

P. haloplanktis is regularly able to grow at temperatures as low as -2.5°C and as high as 29°C, but it grows fastest around 15°C. The gap between the temperature at which the bacteria thrive and at which they die leaves headroom for evolution to occur in between, says Toll-Riera. If anything could rapidly evolve a way to deal with heat, P. haloplanktis was it.

After between 70 and 270 generations at 30°C, the bacteria were able to grow well. They evolved to survive 1°C above their usual maximum of 29°C. But they hit a limit. When the researchers exposed the bacteria to temperatures beyond 30°C, they could barely grow, and they couldn’t grow at all above 32°C. Even for this microbial escape artist “it seems that it’s not so easy to evolve”, says Toll-Riera.

The finding adds “a note of realism” to the notion that many species can survive rapid environmental change through evolution, says at McGill University in Canada. “A hard limit applies even in an organism which is evolving as rapidly as any cellular organism can,” he says.

The study could also help explain why such a limit exists. The researchers found many of the same genetic variants occurred in populations evolving in parallel. Several variants made proteins more stable; others enhanced an enzyme that destroys misfolded proteins. It could be that protein misfolding imposes a limit on adaptation to heat, says Toll-Riera.

Toll-Riera is cautious about generalising far beyond bacteria in a lab but says other research has found “hard limits” to adaptations to increasing temperatures in laboratory studies of tropical fish.

“We’re already seeing these mass mortality events when heat waves hit,” says at the University of Bergen in Norway. “You can already see that the thermal limits are being exceeded for many species.”

Evolution isn’t the only route to survival. “Evolutionary rescue is hard, but that doesn’t say that organisms cannot respond to heat waves,” says Toll-Riera. Species can migrate or adapt in ways that don’t involve genetic change. But evolution alone probably isn’t enough.

Science Advances

Article amended on 18 July 2022

We have corrected what the 2°C increase refers to.

Topics: Bacteria / Climate change / Evolution