èƵ

UK minister says EU is ‘weaponising science’ in Brexit deal row

The UK is making plans to launch its own science funding programme in September, science minister George Freeman tells èƵ, if the EU refuses access to the Horizon scheme
UK science minister George Freeman
UK science minister George Freeman
Tayfun Salci/ZUMA Press Wire/Shutterstock

The UK will launch its own version of the European Union’s €100 billion Horizon research scheme in September if a deal on continued access cannot be reached, says the UK science minister, George Freeman. Freeman has accused the EU of “weaponising science” as the UK’s continued participation in Horizon, the largest collaborative research programme in the world looks increasingly unlikely.

As part of the Brexit withdrawal agreement signed in December 2020, the EU agreed to allow the UK to remain part of the Horizon programme, into which the UK would pay £15 billion over seven years. In return, UK scientists get access to grants from the European Research Council (ERC), with the UK being the second largest recipient of grants from 2014 to 2020.

The UK’s attempt to override part of the deal relating to the transport of goods , however, has left planned continued participation in Horizon – and other collaborations such as the Copernicus Earth observation programme and the Euratom nuclear collaboration – in doubt.

Earlier this month, awarded in 2021 unless the UK sticks to the original Brexit agreement.

Freeman tells èƵ he is worried that scientists are being punished for a disagreement they aren’t part of. “It’s very disappointing the EU are actively ringing up ERC grant nominees and using them as pawns in negotiations,” he says. “We’re pretty fed up that we are still being held out. The EU is weaponising science for the Northern Ireland negotiations.”

“If you’d asked me in the spring if we’d leave Horizon, I felt that common sense would prevail,” he says. “My working assumption now, unless the phone rings, is that is where we are and I have a duty to roll out an alternative programme.”

The UK’s membership of Horizon expires at the end of 2022, but Freeman says if a resolution can’t be found in the next few weeks, then he would begin preparations to launch his alternative, currently known as Plan B. A prospectus on how Plan B will work is set to be published before MPs leave Parliament for their summer break on 21 July.

Freeman says the plan would be “ready to deploy this September”, giving UK scientists access to research grants and covering the loss of any ERC grants up to the end of 2022.

“There is a whole world beyond the EU,” says Freeman. “There’s a big opportunity for us to deploy the money for global projects.”

Several countries outside the EU have signalled their intent to join Horizon, however, including New Zealand, Japan, Canada and South Korea.

A spokesperson for the European Commission said they “continue to recognise the mutual benefit in cooperation in science, research and innovation, nuclear research and space”. However, there were “serious difficulties” regarding the withdrawal agreement. “The Commission’s objective remains to have a stable and positive relationship with the UK,” they said.

Unless the situation regarding Northern Ireland can be resolved, it looks increasingly likely that the UK will no longer be part of Horizon by September.

Topics: Politics / UK