żěè¶ĚĘÓƵ

Fate of buried Java Man revealed in unseen notes from Homo erectus dig

One of the first excavations to find extinct human remains took place on Java in the 1890s, and the original documentation reveals details about the mudflow that encased the fossils there
RCHDGR . Die Pithecanthropus-Schichten auf Java. Geologische und palaontologische Ergebnisse der Trinil-Expedition (1907 und 1908), ausgefuhrt mit Unterstutzung der Akademischen Jubilaumsstiftung der Stadt Berlin und der Koniglich bayerischen Akademi der Wissenschaften. Geology; Paleontology; Homo erectus. Sdenka-Trinu-Expedition. Tafel III.. Please note that these images are extracted from scanned page images that may have been digitally enhanced for readability - coloration and appearance of these illustrations may not perfectly resemble the original work.. Selenka, Lenore; Blanckenhorn, Max Ludwig
Archaeological dig in Indonesia where the Java Man fossils were found
public domain sourced / access rights from Paul Fearn / Alamy Stock Photo

The first large excavation of ancient human remains in Indonesia, in the 1890s, were done with great care – according to an analysis of unpublished documents from the dig.

The original excavations revealed that Homo erectus on Java lived in a lush valley alongside a range of large animals, including antelope and elephants. Researchers including at the Naturalis Biodiversity Center in the Netherlands have analysed the records, and they say the animals in the fossil bed may all have perished in a single cataclysm, probably a volcanic eruption. Later, a volcanic mudslide swept all their bones down the valley to a single site.

Homo erectus was one of the first of , to which our species, Homo sapiens, belongs, and the first known to have lived outside Africa. It was first described by Eugène Dubois, a Dutch researcher who, in the late 19th century, travelled to what is now in search of fossils of the “missing link” between apes and humans. Between 1891 and 1893, at a site called on the banks of the Solo river on Java, ’s team excavated the first recognised remains of what he called Pithecanthropus erectus – now known as H. erectus.

The initial report was based on three pieces: a molar tooth, a skullcap and a femur or thigh bone. The discovery helped kick-start the study of human evolution, but many researchers have long been sceptical about the femur. “It looks too much like Homo sapiens,” says Albers. This has led to suggestions that that had sunk deep into the soil.

Albers and his colleagues have gone back over the original Trinil documents, most of which were never published. They include letters between Dubois and his site staff, letters from Dubois to the Indies government (as it was then called) and notes Dubois scribbled on unpublished photographs.

The team concludes that Dubois ran a careful excavation, particularly by the standards of the time. “He was well ahead,” says Albers. For instance, although his published papers provide only scanty information about the geological setting, during the excavation he was one of the first to divide a site into metre-by-metre squares, ensuring each discovery could be precisely localised. This rigorous approach suggests the femur really is H. erectus, says Albers.

“It’s really important to revisit some of these older sites,” says at Midwestern University in Arizona.

In the same sediments where the H. erectus remains were found, Dubois and his colleagues also discovered bones of large mammals. They included an antlered deer called Axis lydekkeri, an antelope-like creature called Duboisia santeng and an elephant called Stegodon trigonocephalus. All these animals are now extinct, but roamed the Solo river valley alongside H. erectus . Albers says it is likely that H. erectus ate at least some of them, as the species is known for hunting large animals, but there is no direct evidence of that at this site, so we can’t be sure.

This is all “pretty consistent with what a number of people have said”, says Baab.

All in all, Indonesia offered a rich ecosystem for H. erectus, but it also had dangers, as revealed by the types of rock Dubois excavated at the site. The islands are volcanically active, and Albers and his colleagues think that is why the Trinil bone bed was so rich.

Dubois noted that many of the animal bones are broken, but don’t have much surface damage, and there are no cut marks that would suggest they were killed by H. erectus. This suggests the animals experienced something catastrophic, but that their bones didn’t spend much time being bounced around in the Solo river – so they must have come from nearby.

The most likely explanation is a volcanic eruption that killed hundreds of animals at once, says Albers. They may have died from breathing toxic fumes, he says. Afterwards, there was a lahar, a mudflow filled with rocks ejected from the volcano. The lahar swept the bones to the same site and entombed them in mud.

“People have talked about it potentially being related to lahars, but I thought that was a nice addition to knowledge that we had before,” says Baab.

Reference: BioRxiv, DOI:

Sign up to Our Human Story, a free monthly newsletter on the revolution in archaeology and human evolution

Topics: Ancient humans / Archaeology