èƵ

Moon mystery could be solved by simulation of planetary smash-up

The moon is thought to have been created in a violent collision, and a new simulation of the event could answer questions that have puzzled astrophysicists
Artwork of the young Earth-Moon system. The Earth had recently formed when it was struck by a protoplanet called Theia roughly three times the size of Mars. Debris from the impact went into orbit, while the cores of the two planets merged. Within weeks of the event, the debris formed a Saturn-like ring around the Earth. Later collisions in this ring led to the formation of the Moon, probably within just a few thousand years. Initially the Earth and Moon were much closer together than they are now, and spinning more quickly.
Artwork of the collision that gave rise to the moon
MARK GARLICK/SCIENCE PHOTO LIBRARY

A computer simulation that traces the moon’s formation in high resolution may explain the mystery of why it is so chemically similar to Earth.

The conventional story for the moon’s origin is that a primordial planet named Theia smashed into Earth and spewed molten rock into space. This debris, primarily made up of Theia, then coalesced into the moon over tens of millions of years.

While this scenario accounts the moon’s observed angular momentum, it fails to explain the near-identical profile of the moon’s isotopes to those found on Earth. Isotopes are atoms of the same element that differ by the amount of neutrons they contain, and the ratio of different isotopes in a sample can be used to trace where it originated from.

at Durham University, UK, and his colleagues ran more than 400 high-resolution simulations of what might have happened when the early Earth was struck, using different initial conditions like impact angle and speed. The model simulated the behaviour of hundreds of millions of particles to map the collision, far more than previous attempts, which had used at most hundreds of thousands.

Many of the simulations produced satellites similar to our moon within hours – much more quickly than other models have suggested. They resulted in a moon with a similar angular momentum and isotopic make-up to Earth, which means that the moon contains more of Earth and less of Theia than previous models. The findings were presented at the Lunar and Planetary Science Conference in The Woodlands, Texas, on 10 March.

“It’s interesting that simulations in this work lead to more mixing between the impactor and proto-Earth than previous work suggested,” says at the University of Rochester in New York. “This would help explain the isotopic similarities between Earth and the moon.”

One way to test the model’s validity would be by looking at the volatile elements that it predicts for the moon, says Nakajima. The moon contains less of these easily vaporisable elements like potassium and sodium that are found on Earth, which in conventional models is thought to be a result of the moon’s long coalescence from debris. “It would be interesting to investigate whether their model can explain the observation that the moon is depleted in volatiles,” says Nakajima.

Sign up to our free Launchpad newsletter for a voyage across the galaxy and beyond, every Friday

Article amended on 16 March 2022

We clarified how many particles the model simulated.

Topics: Astrophysics