èƵ

Mercury’s outer layers may have been stripped off by a young Venus

Mercury is mostly iron, which may be because a series of close encounters with a young Venus billions of years ago stripped away its rocky outer layers
Mercury
A false colour view of Mercury’s cratered surface
NASA/Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory/Arizona State University/Carnegie Institution of Washington. Image reproduced courtesy of Science/AAAS.

Mercury may have been robbed by Venus in the early days of the solar system. A series of close passes between the two planets when they were young could have stripped away Mercury’s outer layers, leaving behind a world that is mostly dense core.

Mercury’s iron core makes up 70 per cent of its mass, a much higher proportion than any other rocky planet in the solar system. To end up like this, something must have happened to Mercury to strip away its mantle, the thick layer between the crust and core.

The simple answer is that a young Mercury underwent a collision that melted its outer layers – we think a similar collision on Earth formed the moon. But the Messenger spacecraft, which orbited Mercury between 2011 and 2015, spotted signs of elements such as potassium that would have vaporised in the heat of a collision. If a smash-up made Mercury so strange, it shouldn’t have those elements.

Now Hongping Deng at the University of Cambridge has used simulations to show that it may have been a series of near misses instead. “If you pass by without direct contact, there is much less heat generated,” he says. “It just peels off the mantle.”

You can see this in the simulation video below, where Mercury is the smaller of the two bodies. Purple corresponds to the outer mantle, while green is the dense core.

[video_player id=”Twme6GGv” access_level=”everyone”]

Mercury probably started out about 30 per cent iron by mass, which is the iron fraction of the oldest rocks in the solar system. Deng found that if the young Mercury was spinning in the right way, its mantle would have been relatively easy to detach, meaning it would take four close encounters with the young Venus to raise the iron fraction to its present-day value.

Previous simulations of the early solar system have predicted multiple near passes between the two planets as they grew, so this is a plausible scenario, Deng says.

If this drive-by theft did occur, it would be hard to catch Venus with the stolen goods – Mercury is roughly 10 per cent the mass of Venus, and its mantle just a fraction of the whole mass, meaning material originating from Mercury would be hard to find on present day Venus.

Instead, we need to study Mercury more closely to tell for certain how it formed. “I think obtaining in situ geochemical analyses or analysing a sample in Earth-based laboratories [would] be extremely useful for determining its formation mechanism,” says Kathleen Vander Kaaden at the Lunar and Planetary Institute in Texas.

We won’t have to wait too much longer for a closer look. The BepiColombo spacecraft is on its way to Mercury and will arrive in 2025. As it orbits Mercury, it is expected to reveal hints from the surface of how the planet was born, says Vander Kaaden.

The Astrophysical Journal Letters

Topics: Planets / Solar system