èƵ

Loss of the UK’s ash trees due to fungal disease may cost £15 billion

Ash dieback, a fungal disease in the UK’s ash trees, could cost the country nearly £15 billion in clean-up and lost ecosystem benefits like carbon sequestration
Ash tree with shrivelled leaves
Ash dieback will be costly to the environment and the economy
David Mark / Alamy Stock Photo

The death of virtually all Britain’s ash trees due to a fungal disease will cost more than just lost habitats for wildlife and treasured woods for recreation. A new estimate of the economic cost of ash dieback, a fungal disease that arrived in the UK in 2012, puts the price tag at £14.8 billion.

That’s about three times as much as estimates for the Dutch elm disease crisis in the 1960s and 70s, largely because there are far more ash trees. It is also a third more than the cost of the 2001 outbreak of foot-and-mouth disease in the UK.

“The message is government is not taking plant security seriously enough, this potential colossal cost is being ignored,” says Nick Atkinson at the University of Oxford. He and his colleagues collected data on clean-up and replacement costs for lost trees, and took into account the lost value of ecosystems.

They found that over 100 years, this disease will cost the UK nearly £15 billion, though around half of that burden is expected to fall over the next decade. That’s because a large chunk of the costs, almost £5 billion, come from having to fell the trees near roadsides and in towns and cities for safety reasons.

The single biggest cost is the £9 billion loss of the ecosystem services – the clean air, water and carbon sequestration – that the trees provide.

The financial burden will fall overwhelmingly on public authorities, though it will hit some landowners too. Lincolnshire county council and Devon county council are estimated to be worst hit, with the latter facing a £30 million annual bill in tree felling.

It’s not clear whether ash dieback will kill off 135 million of the 150 million ash trees in the UK, as the new study assumes, but Atkinson says different mortality rates would make only minor differences to the final bill.

Economic cost aside, Atkinson says the death of ash, which are key in UK hedgerows and one of the few trees to grow on the country’s windswept moorlands, will be a major blow for nature and landscapes. “It’s part of glue that holds British countryside together,” he says.

Current Biology

Topics: Economics / Environment / Plants