èƵ

Our primate ancestors may have originated in Europe or North America

It was thought that the ancestor we share with lemurs, monkeys and apes evolved in Asia, but fossil analysis suggests this may not have been the case
We share an ancestor with lemurs, but we don’t know what it was
Joel Sartore/National Geographic

Our distant primate ancestors are thought to have arisen in Asia, but new evidence challenges this assumption, suggesting primates may instead have evolved in Europe or North America.

Primates include all lemurs, monkeys, apes and humans. The oldest confirmed primate fossils are about 56 million years old, so were formed 10 million years after the extinction that wiped out all dinosaurs except birds. This time is called the Palaeocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum because the average global temperature rose by 5°C or more in a few thousand years. Many ocean species died out, but life on land flourished. Primates emerged, as did the first hoofed mammals.

The established story has been that primates appeared at this time in Asia, says anthropologist Paul Morse. This is based on the discovery in China of several fossils of primitive primates that resemble miniature monkeys or bushbabies. These include Archicebus achilles as well as Teilhardina asiatica, which is thought to be one of the earliest primates.

But other Teilhardina species have been found elsewhere, and seem to be just as old. These include Teilhardina belgica in Europe and Teilhardina brandti and several other species in ǰٳ.

To better understand early primates, Morse – while working at the Florida Museum of Natural History – and his colleagues collected 163 new T. brandti fossils from the Bighorn Basin in Wyoming, and compared them with other Teilhardina species (Journal of Human Evolution, ).

“What we found, once we had evaluated the variation within .Իپ, was that it closely resembled the animal from China [],” he says. “. also has some of these characteristics. They’re all about on par with one another in their primitiveness.”

That means T. asiatica cannot be reliably distinguished from either Europe’s T. belgica or North America’s T. brandti.

“Wherever primates began, the group spread remarkably rapidly once they had emerged”

If we can’t determine which fossil is the most primitive, we also can’t tell where primates evolved. Morse emphasises that he isn’t claiming North America is their cradle, rather than Asia, but that the question remains open.

However, Christopher Beard at the University of Kansas, who co‑discovered A. achilles, argues that primates must have arisen in Asia, by process of elimination. “There’s nothing in either Europe or North America that’s a likely ancestor for these things,” he says. “So I think most of us have basically given up on Europe and North America being places where these animals might have originally evolved.” He points to Asian groups of tree shrews and the lemur-like gliding colugos as potential ancestors of primates.

But Morse thinks that the extinct plesiadapiforms – a large group of squirrel-like animals that lived in Asia, Europe and North America – could have given rise to the first primates. “Some aspects of their teeth closely resemble the teeth of early primates,” says Morse. A few plesiadapiforms seem to have adaptations in their ankles that closely resemble features seen in early primates that are thought to have been used for grasping, he says.

Regardless of where primates began, the group spread remarkably rapidly once they had emerged. “How did they go from being nowhere to being on all three northern continents?” asks Morse.

He thinks the spread of forests, driven by the warmer climate, gave them an uninterrupted habitat through which to move.

This article appeared in print under the headline “Rethinking the origins of primates”

Tracing our origins

Fossils have been crucial in understanding the history of primates. Here are four of the most important finds.

Purgatorius

These squirrel-like North American mammals suggest primates could have originated 66 million years ago, but many dispute whether they are true primates.

Eosimias sinensis

The “dawn monkey of China” lived a little over 40 million years ago. Some claim it was the first simian, the group that includes monkeys, apes and humans.

Proconsul

Living in Africa around 24 million years ago, this was one of the first apes. Over the next 10 million years, apes diversified and spread, turning Earth into a real planet of the apes.

Sahelanthropus tchadensis

The oldest hominin fossil yet identified is at least 6 million years old and was found in Chad.

Topics: human evolution