
Artistic talent may really be linked to a higher likelihood of experiencing mental health conditions, according to a study of people in Sweden.
The Greek philosopher Plato noted that creative types often seemed to possess “divine madness” – a stereotype later applied to Vincent Van Gogh, Salvador Dalí and Edvard Munch. However, good studies on the subject have been lacking.
Now at Kings College London and his colleagues have pored over the health and education records of the entire population of Sweden, focusing on the mental health of people who had done subjects like art, music or drama at university.
Advertisement
Art students
They found that those who had studied an artistic subject were 90 per cent more likely to be hospitalised for schizophrenia, compared with the general population. Such people were also 62 per cent more likely to be admitted for bipolar disorder, and 39 per cent more likely to be admitted for depression.
These hospitalisations usually occurred after university, most commonly in people’s mid-30s. Those with law degrees did not have the same elevated risks, suggesting psychiatric conditions are not simply linked to university education, says MacCabe.
The findings are consistent with of 86,000 people in Iceland, which found that artists, musicians and other creative professionals were slightly more likely to have genetic variants linked to schizophrenia and bipolar disorder.
It may be that the same genetic variants that unleash creativity can also trigger mental conditions, says MacCabe. “Creativity often involves linking ideas or concepts in ways that other people wouldn’t think of,” he says. “But that’s similar to how delusions work – for example, seeing a connection between the colour of someone’s clothes and being part of an MI5 conspiracy.”
Slightly more common
People who feel things deeply may have more internal creative inspiration but greater emotional instability, says MacCabe. “Someone who is moved to tears by looking at a painting may have greater artistic sensitivity but also be more vulnerable to depression,” he says.
But the study has some limitations, including the way it used arts degrees as a proxy for creativity. “It’s not ideal because many highly creative people are not studying art,” says Shelley Carson at Harvard University.
Artists shouldn’t feel too worried because the risks are small, says Jeremy Hall at Cardiff University. In the Sweden study, schizophrenia still only affected 1 in 115 artistic people.
“My advice to artists would be the same as to anyone else worried about developing psychosis,” says Hall. “Don’t smoke cannabis and try to lead a generally healthy life.”
British Journal of Psychiatry
This article appeared in print under the headline “Creative people have more mental health issues”