èƵ

Ancient Swedish massacre hints at chaos after the fall of Rome

The inhabitants of Sandby borg in southern Sweden were violently killed 1500 years ago, just decades after the collapse of the Western Roman Empire
The skeleton of a teenager found in Sandby borg
The skeleton of a teenager found in Sandby borg
Kalmar County Museum

An ancient Swedish fort is beginning to relinquish a dark secret it has held for 1500 years – that its walls bore witness to a brutal massacre. Although it’s unclear exactly what motivated the apparently merciless attack, it was probably linked to the chaos that swept across northern Europe following the collapse of the Western Roman Empire.

on the island of Öland was an impressive ringfort in the late 5th century. Its walls stood 5 metres tall and enclosed a 5000-square-metre area that contained about 50 dwellings. Archaeological work began in 2010, but the ringfort is so rich in ancient finds that to date only about 6 per cent of the site has been excavated.

The remains of Sandby borg
The remains of Sandby borg
Sebastian Jakobsson

Those excavations are revealing an extraordinary picture of violence and disorder. The remains of at least 26 individuals of all ages – including a baby and a young child – have been unearthed in the ringfort’s houses and streets. Many show signs of violent injury. They were seemingly slaughtered by invaders and left where they fell.

“We anticipate that more bodies will be found,” says at Kalmar County Museum, Sweden. “We’ve estimated that a fully inhabited fort of this size would have housed some 150-250 people. The total death toll may well be around those figures.”

Papmehl-Dufay and his colleagues have also discovered valuables scattered around the site, including exquisite gold and silver artefacts and the remains of livestock. This suggests that the attackers weren’t opportunistic plunderers and may have had other motivations for their actions.

A silver brooch, one of many valuable artefacts seemingly left behind
A silver brooch, one of many valuable artefacts seemingly left behind
Daniel Lindskog

For the moment those motives remain unclear. But it may be no coincidence that Sandby borg was attacked just decades after the fall of the Western Roman Empire.

Although Scandinavia was always beyond Rome’s direct influence, it didn’t escape the shift in power dynamics that resulted from the empire’s collapse. Ringforts like Sandby borg might have emerged as seats of local power, according to Papmehl-Dufay’s team, making them prominent targets for attack by others with ambitions to rule.

It would be cruelly apt if the fall of the Western Roman Empire led to violence in northern Europe – because the rise of Rome centuries earlier also did so.

Scenes of mass violence became far more common across the region from about 200 BC, says at Aarhus University in Denmark. “One of the reasons we begin to see these scenes is because of the pressure from the expansion of Rome, which led to local conflicts.”

This might give the impression that the rise of Rome left northern Europe in a perpetual state of chaos.

But in a paper published in February, Løvschal and her colleague argued that northern Europe’s mass conflicts quickly took on a religious significance. This suggests they helped maintain an uneasy social order ().

Researcher Clara Alfsdotter examines one of the skulls
Researcher Clara Alfsdotter examines one of the skulls
Daniel Lindskog

After battles or massacres, the dead and their weapons were often carefully treated in a way that might have impressed and intimidated locals, and discouraged insurrection. For instance, at one site in France there is evidence that . “It was an army of death that decayed over several generations,” says Løvschal.

Such rituals were generally less macabre in Scandinavia. Typically, the weapons of war were collected and deposited in marshy bogs. However, Løvschal and Holst argue these “war bogs” were still sites of powerful symbolic significance that helped governing elites stay in control.

The Sandby borg massacre doesn’t seem to belong to that governing tradition, says Løvschal. Livestock and other valuables at the ringfort were not sacrificed or ritually treated, but simply abandoned. The ringfort’s walls and houses eventually collapsed, burying the dead exactly as they had fallen. As such, the massacre might be evidence that northern Europe’s governing elites had lost influence and control, following the collapse of the Western Roman Empire.

“The fact that the victims were not buried, and seemingly not manipulated at all after the massacre, actually seems to be highly unusual,” says Papmehl-Dufay. This lack of treatment suggests the massacre broke accepted social conventions in some way, he says.

Antiquity

Topics: Archaeology / History / Religion / War