èƵ

The forces that govern matter and light could be united at last

A new grand unified theory seems to unite electromagnetism and the weak and strong nuclear force without resorting to supersymmetry
A big explosion in space
How were the fundamental forces unified just after the big bang?
Detlev Van Ravenswaay/Science Photo Library

Immediately after the big bang, there was just one force. As the universe cooled, this force split into two, then three, and then the four forces of today’s universe. Physicists have long been searching for a grand unified theory that combines everything except gravity into one force. Now, a new idea does just that, but without making predictions that had jinxed earlier attempts.

Of the four fundamental forces – gravity, electromagnetism, and the weak and strong nuclear forces – experiments at particle colliders have shown that electromagnetism and the weak nuclear force become one “electroweak” force at energies of about 100 gigaelectronvolts (GeV). This takes us back to about a trillionth of a second after the big bang.

“But the question is what happened after one trillionth of a trillionth of a trillionth of a second after the big bang?” says at the University of California San Diego. In principle, the electroweak and strong nuclear force should have become one force.

Fornal and , also at UCSD, have now built a grand unified theory on an earlier idea called SU(5), but crucially without requiring that protons should decay.

Breaking symmetry

SU(5) was proposed in 1974 by Howard Georgi and Sheldon Glashow. In SU(5), at the high energies of grand unification, all the particles are represented by mathematical structures that can be thought of as pentagons and decagons.

Take the pentagon. Each side of the pentagon represents either a quark or a lepton, which are fundamental particles. But mathematically, the sides of the pentagon are identical – so there’s no way in this model to tell apart a quark from a lepton. It’s only when the universe cools that this symmetry breaks, and this metaphorical pentagon shatters into pieces, each of which now represents either a quark or a lepton.

One side effect of SU(5) is that it predicts an extra interaction between quarks and leptons. This makes protons liable to decay, for instance, when two of the three quarks that make up a proton spontaneously turn into a lepton and an antiquark

But experiments like the Super-Kamiokande neutrino observatory in Japan, which have been looking for the radiation released by decaying protons, have seen nothing. They have put the lifetime of a proton at more than 1034 years, orders of magnitude more than what’s predicted by SU(5).

There are theories that predict longer proton lifetimes, but they are far more complicated. For example, grand unified theories can incorporate supersymmetry, which doubles the number of known particles. This can extend the lifetime of protons. But experiments at the Large Hadron Collider at CERN have seen no evidence of supersymmetry either.

Adding dark matter

In their new grand-unified model, Fornal and Grinstein have added two structures to SU(5), one with 40 sides and another with 50 sides. These structures represent heavy fields, which both help unify the electroweak and strong nuclear forces, and also prevent the proton from decaying.

“It’s a proof of concept that such a theory can be constructed,” says Fornal. And the duo has done it without resorting to supersymmetry. “We pride ourselves on constructing a non-supersymmetric theory,” says Fornal.

, who studies grand unified theories at the University of Split, Croatia, is impressed. He says this “demonstrates once again the richness and beauty of this mature subject”. But, the proof of concept can be refuted if proton decay is observed, he says.

The next step is to see if the theory can explain why the mass of the recently discovered Higgs boson is less than expected, Fornal says. “Instead of doing the usual nip and tuck to make the Higgs fit their theory,” Fornal says, “there might be a way to solve this by adding extra fields into the theory.”

Sometimes, such tweaks are needed to make the observed universe add up mathematically. The Higgs field was added to solve just such a problem – the origin of mass for all particles – and that turned out to be correct.

The team also wants to see if the theory can be modified to incorporate a candidate particle for dark matter, which would require a more general unified group of dark matter plus all the forces and particles we know of. When the symmetry breaks in that case, dark matter would fall out as a candidate particle.

ArXiv,

Read more: Reality guide: The essential laws of cosmology

Article amended on 21 November 2017

Correction: This article has been amended to clarify what happens during the decay of protons.

Topics: electromagnetism / Particle physics