
WHAT does a pet grooming service in Florida have to do with Chinese internet censorship? Every day, China’s government subtly redirects swathes of its citizens to the offering beauty treatments for dogs and cats – though it is a mystery why.
Citizens attempting to access banned sites and being dispatched to strange corners of the global internet is just one of the findings to emerge from a study of China’s murky regime of internet censorship. There is also evidence that China has a centrally coordinated plan – unevenly applied across the country – to “poison” internet servers with false information. This comes at a time when information control will be on the minds of the Chinese authorities, in light of the in November and a major leadership transition in government.
China’s “golden shield” – aka the great firewall – is arguably the most sophisticated and pervasive online censorship operation in the world. A number of international groups have been trying to bring some transparency. For example, the Herdict project at the Berkman Center For Internet and Society at Harvard University has turned to crowdsourcing to keep track of blocked sites in China and elsewhere. Anybody who lives in a censored region can report inaccessible sites on . As of late November, the sites most often reported as blocked in China included Twitter and Facebook, news sites like the BBC and political sites like .
Advertisement
Intrigued by the efforts of Herdict, Joss Wright at the Oxford Internet Institute based at the University of Oxford wanted to find out more about Chinese censorship. The censors employ various techniques, ranging from blunt blocking to more subtle ploys like giving the .
Wright monitored the responses of 187 “Domain Name System” servers throughout China. These servers are the internet’s phone books. Before you access a website, your browser must visit a DNS server to discover the IP address of the site. This string of numbers tells your computer where to connect to.
Wright asked the servers for their responses for 80 of the sites most often reported as blocked on Herdict. For many sites – , for instance – DNS servers replied with “does not exist”. Others gave unexpected misdirections to other IP addresses. This is called DNS poisoning. “It’s like having the wrong number in the phone book,” says Wright.
That’s where The Pet Club in Miami comes in. Wright found that when people in China try to access – a tool that prevents online tracking – they instead often get the IP address of . Other Chinese DNS servers are sending people to blank pages or single computers in Azerbaijan, Ireland, the US, Italy and New Zealand. In November, China temporarily blocked Google and many of its services using DNS poisoning, redirecting people to an IP address in South Korea.
The tactic makes sense for a censor who wants to control information without fomenting activism, as a redirection could seem like a glitch. Also, by monitoring traffic to an obscure site outside China that a Chinese user would be unlikely to visit by chance, the censors might find it easier to keep track of online behaviour, speculates Wright.
“Redirection makes sense for a censor who wants to control information without fomenting activism”
Wright’s findings also led him to deduce how censorship is applied within China. His monitoring revealed some regions are stricter than others: Beijing was more censored than Shanghai, for example. Still, he also found fingerprints of a central coordinator. Curiously, The Pet Club poisoning and a number of others are applied by different DNS servers, operated by different firms, all across China. Somebody central must have handed a list of redirections to all the regional censors, including the one for thepetclubfl.net. Wright has submitted his research to the journal .
The idea that censorship is applied to varying degrees within China rings true to Ryan Budish, Herdict’s director. “It’s not correct to think of Chinese filtering as a monolithic thing,” he says. Still, the regime is undeniably effective. “The one thing to know about Chinese filtering is that it’s incredibly persistent, and has been for years.”
So, with new leaders in place, where next for Chinese net censorship? Budish believes the censors’ biggest challenge will be monitoring microblogging sites, particularly weibo.com, China’s version of Twitter. “The speed at which content is generated is immense,” he says. “Policing that is going to be difficult.”
No one knows why the censors picked The Pet Club’s website. Until now, Dennis Bost of Universal Merchant Solutions in Hollywood, Florida, who set up the website for the salon owners, had been puzzled by the web traffic he’d been seeing. “I’m amazed at the number of hits they get from China,” he says. “They’re a grooming salon. No one is popping over from Beijing to have their Shar Pei groomed.”
The Pet Club owners haven’t asked about their website traffic, so would have no idea, says Bost. “It seems to come and go, and when I see it, I do scratch my head. I think ‘what the hell is this?’ “
How to really offend the censors
What gets a site blocked in China? Sometimes, the reasons are obscure. For instance, an apparently benign camera review site – – is often reported blocked. For other sites, it’s more obvious. Facebook has been blocked since 2009, apparently after being used during riots in the city of Urumqi. Other sites, like Twitter and YouTube, are presumably blocked because the state would struggle to monitor everything posted on them. Political sites like Wikileaks are obviously off the menu. China also blocks access to tools used to evade censorship, like . Anyone that irks the authorities is punished. The New York Times was blocked this month after publishing .
Top 10 sites most reported as blocked last year (according to )
(reviews)
(social media)
(video sharing)
(news site)
(social media)
(photo-sharing site)
(social media)
(URL used to hide your Google searches)
(cloud service)
(blogging host)