èƵ

Feedback: Rhubarb, invisible rhubarb

Wireless network blocked by rhubarb, quantum train stations, GPS for the pernickety, a memory card is a memory card is a memory card, and more

Rhubarb, invisible rhubarb

THE “Wakefield triangle” – in which Paul Barker’s attempts to get a wireless connection on the train produced the warning “No map contains our current position” – is not as “unexpected” as we thought (11 June).

The box of carpet cleaner that Sara Davies ordered online arrived sternly labelled “Multi-item set – do not open”. We still haven’t heard how she got the stuff out

Norman McCanch is one of many readers who told us so. He writes: “Purely to confirm my reputation as a pedantic old fossil, can I mention that this term has long been used to describe ‘the Rhubarb triangle’ – a 23-square-kilometre area in West Yorkshire, UK, famous for producing early forced rhubarb.”

Could this be true? A quick search confirmed it. We found that growing this type of rhubarb is a highly skilled craft that among other things involves keeping the growing plants in total darkness in sheds for several weeks. Many websites – see for example – assert that rhubarb produced in this way is exceptionally delicious and that the forced rhubarb from the Wakefield triangle is an “undeniably superior product”. Indeed, we find that the triangle’s rhubarb farmers applied in 2005 for , the European Union equivalent of “appellation d’origine contrôlée“. This was finally granted in February 2010.

On a note closer to home, èƵ‘s Yorkshire-reared production editor Mick O’Hare tells us that his father had a forced rhubarb shed and he recalls “the dampness and the smell of candles”. He also confirms what the websites tell us – that during each season until the 1960s an overnight train known as the Rhubarb Express ran from Wakefield to London so that the rhubarb could be sold at dawn in Covent Garden market.

One question remains. Why was Paul Barker’s computer unable to work out its location when it passed through the Wakefield triangle? Could the fact that it was surrounded by rhubarb at the time have anything to do with it? Is there perhaps a substance in rhubarb leaves that knocks out computers – or that makes the rhubarb and its surroundings invisible to surveillance systems, like the vegetable equivalent of a stealth bomber? Further research is needed.

Meanwhile, Feedback salutes the triangle’s rhubarb growers and refers readers to the splendid statue of a giant rhubarb that has been erected in Wakefield to celebrate the region’s horticultural and gastronomic significance (see ).

The two-slit railway breakthrough

QUANTUM transportation appears to be developing more rapidly than the classical kind. We first became aware of the instruction on London’s Underground to “use all doors to exit” (16 June 2007) and the instruction to Parisian pedestrians to “cross the road in two times” (29 November 2008). Now, delving into Feedback’s notorious filing system, we come across a report from October 2010 on BBC news online of an incident in which passengers made an unauthorised departure from a broken-down train. That train, we were informed, “also called at Hertfordshire”.

The county of Hertfordshire, just north of London, covers 1643 square kilometres. Could the breakdown have been due to the train in question passing through two slits and subsequently calling, as a wave function, at the entire area simultaneously?

The BBC has, to its credit, since responded to reader demands to collapse that wave function and amended the story to have the train calling at “stops in Hertfordshire”.

Sub-atomic global positioning

ONE of the apps Barry Matthew uses on his Palm Pre smartphone calculates his GPS coordinates. He was intrigued to find that it attempts to be accurate to 15 decimal places. He sends us a screen shot which gives “GPS accuracy” of 37.947330474853516 metres. What can this mean? Barry thinks it means he can know his position to within about 1 electron radius.

“Hooray!” he exclaims.         

We, on the other hand, suspect that his phone has failed to round up to a 38-metre radius – so it is being incredibly precise about a location accuracy that’s actually quite vague.

Hidden help

WHEN John Gledhill tried to log in to his account on web-hosting company ““, he made an error which prompted this message: “If you are still unable to login, please call our emergency phone line.”

The words “Emergency phone line” were a hyperlink, so he clicked on them, only to be told: “The website declined to show this webpage. Most likely causes: This website requires you to log in.”

“Ho hum,” says John.        

The definition of redundant definition

FINALLY, for the avoidance of doubt, the manual for Drew Rankine’s Canon G12 camera informs: “The various types of memory cards that can be used in this camera are collectively referred to as memory cards in this guide.”

“Now everything’s clear,” observes Drew.

More from èƵ

Explore the latest news, articles and features