èƵ

Tactile illusions 2: Perceptual rivalry

One of the newly discovered tactile illusions uses tapping machines to fool the brain – try the visual equivalent here
The Necker Cube, an impossible object which illustrates the ambiguity of two-dimensional representations of three-dimensional thought (Image: Raul Gonzalez Perez / SPL
The Necker Cube, an impossible object which illustrates the ambiguity of two-dimensional representations of three-dimensional thought (Image: Raul Gonzalez Perez / SPL

Read about all the tactile illusions in our special feature

One of the newly discovered tactile illusions is called “tactile rivalry”, a haptic version of a wider class of illusion called perceptual rivalry.

The best example of perceptual rivalry is the Necker cube, a simple line drawing of a 3D cube that can be interpreted as being viewed from slightly above or slightly below (see diagram). Stare at a Necker cube and the two interpretations spontaneously swap around in your mind’s eye. This is visual rivalry, and it is thought to exist to allow your brain to make sense of ambiguous inputs: when there is no correct answer to the question “what am I looking at?” your brain tries one interpretation, then switches to the other.

Necker cube

Visual rivalry has been used to study vision for more than 200 years, but only recently has it become apparent that other senses do similar things. In 2006 French researchers discovered auditory rivalry, where a stream of electronic beeps can be interpreted in two different ways (listen at ).

Now a touch equivalent has been discovered too. There is no tactile equivalent of the Necker cube, but there is for a similar illusion called visual apparent motion.

Imagine four dots arranged in a square, in which the dots in opposite corners flash on and off alternately (see diagram, or at ). This creates the illusion of two dots moving either horizontally or vertically, or perhaps rotating around the corners of the square. As with the Necker cube, if you stare at it for long enough the motion spontaneously flips from one interpretation to another.

Visual apparent motion

A team led by Christopher Moore at the McGovern Institute for Brain Research at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology recently discovered that the same thing happens with touch. Using a grid of tactile stimulators, they delivered a tactile equivalent of the four flashing dots onto volunteers’ fingertips. Sure enough, the volunteers perceived the dots as moving either horizontally or vertically, and their perceptions spontaneously switched after a minute or so. In touch too, if the brain isn’t sure what it is sensing, it avoids committing you to one interpretation or another ().

Read about all the tactile illusions in our special feature

Topics: Brains / Psychology