WITH 50 million cases in the tropics each year, is humanity鈥檚 most common insect-borne viral infection. Killing the mosquitoes that carry it is the only way to fight it, but now a large-scale survey in Thailand has revealed that this can make the deadliest form of dengue more prevalent.
Known as 鈥渂reakbone fever鈥�, dengue is painful but normally not fatal the first time around 鈥� the real threat is the second infection. There are four varieties, or serotypes. Say you get bitten by a mosquito carrying serotype A, and then a year later by one carrying serotype B. The antibodies you made in response to A bind to the B virus but do not destroy it. Instead these pairs overstimulate the immune system, causing a potentially fatal disease called dengue haemorrhagic fever. DHF kills 12,000 people a year, mainly children.
However, for a few weeks after you contract dengue, you have a kind of immunity that does destroy other serotypes. If you get serotype B during these weeks, you will not develop DHF but will develop antibodies to both A and B. If you get infected by all the serotypes during such a window of cross-immunity, you can end up with antibodies to all of them and won鈥檛 develop DHF.
Advertisement
This led Yoshiro Nagao and colleagues at the to an unusual hypothesis: when there are lots of mosquitoes about, people are more likely to catch another serotype during the brief cross-immunity period, leading to less DHF, but if the number of mosquitoes is reduced, people are infected less frequently and so are less likely to catch another serotype during this crucial window. Catching it later on, however, can cause DHF. This led the team to the counter-intuitive idea that fewer mosquitos could result in more DHF.
To test the hypothesis, they combined the incidence of DHF in Thailand with a huge Thai survey that sampled water containers in a million homes across the country, from 2002 to 2004, looking for larvae of the dengue-carrying Aedes mosquito. The evidence supported the team鈥檚 hypothesis. Where 30 per cent of houses or fewer had mosquitoes, lower infestation rates simply meant less DHF. But if more than 30 per cent were infested, the relationship was reversed: the more homes that were infested, the less DHF there was.
In some villages, 70 per cent of homes had Aedes larvae. A mathematical model based on the survey showed that cutting this to 30 per cent would increase DHF cases by more than 40 per cent (PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases, ). Infestation had to be cut to less than 10 per cent to reduce DHF cases, but achieving such extensive reduction might be difficult, the researchers warn.
The World Health Organization encourages mosquito control 鈥� such as spraying insecticide 鈥� as a means of fighting dengue. But as this may increase the number of DHF cases, such measures should be 鈥渟ubject to ethical discussion鈥�, says Nagao.
Axel Kroeger, a WHO dengue expert, says even if this new discovery is confirmed, it is worth fighting dengue by controlling mosquitoes. This is because some developing countries have achieved far less than 30 per cent infestation, while higher levels often reflect a neglect of mosquito control.
