èƵ

The Aventis Science Prize shortlist 2005

Jon Turney scans the Aventis science prize shortlist

VARIETY is the watchword for this year’s Aventis science book prizes, all the more so, perhaps, thanks to the absence of popular science staples like cosmology. Philip Ball’s Critical Mass, pursuing new insights into group behaviour, offers variety in a single book. As Ball tracks his quarry into many unexpected corners of politics, economics and sociology, he offers a novel take on the links between the history of political philosophy, Newtonian physics and statistical mechanics. The overarching idea that there may be an emerging physics of society is perhaps not completely persuasive, but the journey is intriguing.

With the UK’s general election campaign over, perhaps there is a slim chance that British politicians will take note of Griffith Edwards’s Matters of Substance, in which he attempts to inject some facts and history into the discussion of drugs and why we like them. He distils his lifetime study of drugs in all their forms into a book that combines clarity, sense and even wisdom. Anyone who thinks we should wage a “war on drugs” should be made to read it, as should those who support total legalisation.

More concerned with individual humans is Robert Winston’s The Human Mind. He makes the most of this opportunity to use research that did not make it into the successful BBC TV series. It all slips down easily enough, but suffers from the lack of a clear organising idea. There are a lot of trees here for the reader trying to get a clear picture of the wood.

Douwe Draaisma’s Why Life Speeds Up As You Get Older won prizes when it appeared in Dutch, and is a treasure. Draaisma’s exploration of how our lives are shaped by the remembered past is a wry and literate investigation of the history of psychology and of the human condition. The result is informative, amusing and moving. Long after you close it, it leaves a good memory.

The more familiar main contenders are the two Richards, Fortey and Dawkins. Fortey’s The Earth: An intimate history is an extended tour of how the surface of the planet, and human cultures, have all been shaped by the slow drama of plate tectonics. Fortey tours the sites, from Mount Vesuvius to the San Andreas fault, but never loses sight of the geological point.

Fortey describes The Earth, with its emphasis on people and places, as an anti-textbook. Dawkins’s latest meditation on evolution, tracking it back to its origins through the stories of thousands of earlier organisms, is more like an actual textbook, though an unusually beautiful one. The Ancestor’s Tale is a remarkable achievement; in parts equalling anything he has written. But its aspiration to completeness means it loses out on readability at times.

It would be surprising to see the prize not going to one of the Richards. For Dawkins, it would be a deserved lifetime achievement award, but I suspect Fortey has the edge if the judgement turns on this year’s books. His closing chapter, scanning the whole planet, is a tour de force – the best single piece of writing here. To paraphrase Darwin, there is grandeur in this view of Earth.

Critical Mass: How one thing leads to another

Philip Ball

Arrow Books

Matters of Substance: Drugs – and why everyone’s a user

Griffith Edwards

Allen Lane

The Human Mind: And how to make the most of it

Robert Winston

Bantam

Why Life Speeds Up As You Get Older: How memory shapes our past

Douwe Draaisma

Cambridge University Press

The Earth: An intimate history

Richard Fortey

Perennial

The Ancestor’s Tale: A pilgrimage to the dawn of life

Richard Dawkins

Weidenfeld & Nicolson

More from èƵ

Explore the latest news, articles and features