èƵ

The sun catcher

Take one Hollywood stuntman, a spacecraft and a death-defying helicopter chase and you have the makings of a great movie – or simply NASA's most daring mission yet. Hazel Muir bags a front-row seat

CLIFF FLEMING is no stranger to hair-raising stunts. As a helicopter pilot in the film industry, Hollywood often calls on him to stage a police helicopter shoot-out, or fake a catastrophic crash. In last year’s Vietnam epic We Were Soldiers starring Mel Gibson, for instance, he staged a crash by sending his aircraft diving into a spin and wobbling out of control, leaving the special effects folks to cook up the final explosion.

But one day in September next year, Fleming will take time out from the Hollywood high life to go on a special assignment for NASA – to fly up and grab a little piece of the sun. NASA’s Genesis spacecraft has been soaking up wisps of the solar atmosphere since December 2001, and will return to Earth in September 2004. To minimise the risk of contamination with material from Earth, the spacecraft will drop a canister containing the solar sample into the atmosphere. And, fingers crossed, Fleming’s helicopter will gently catch it in mid-air before the precious cargo can crash to the ground. “It’s kind of exciting,” says Fleming. “It’s not often that you find yourself flying at 10,000 feet to snag something right out of the sky.”

It will be an exciting day for science as well. When researchers have their piece of the sun safely back in the lab, they will be able to use state-of-the-art techniques to find out exactly what our nearest star is made of. The sun is a giant ball of hydrogen and helium, but it also contains a peppering of other, heavier elements that scientists know precious little about. Next year, with a soupçon of sun at their fingertips, they hope to put that right.

This isn’t just about setting the record straight, though. Astronomers hope the Genesis sample will shed light on the birth of the sun and planets. A staggering 99 per cent of all the material in the solar system is held in the sun, and although the chemical make-up of its core constantly changes due to the nuclear reactions that make it shine, the outer layers are thought to preserve the exact composition of the giant interstellar cloud that gave birth to the solar system 4.6 billion years ago.

By studying its chemistry, scientists hope to resolve some of the mysteries about how that big bland cloud transformed itself into the spectacularly diverse bunch of planets, moons and icy comets here today. “Genesis will return a small but precious amount of data crucial to our knowledge of the sun and the formation of our solar system,” says the mission’s head scientist, Donald Burnett of the California Institute of Technology in Pasadena.

The mission began in August 2001, when a spacecraft blasted off on a 3-month journey to a region 1.5 kilometres away from the Earth in the direction of the sun. Since December 2001, the spacecraft has been sampling little specks of the solar wind using five different collector arrays.

Each array is a round panels about 1 metre across, and all five are tiled with 55 palm-sized hexagons of exotic materials such as pure sapphire, diamond, gold and silicon. The materials were selected for their ability to trap specific elements. Experiments on the moon during the late 1960s captured solar particles, but the Genesis plans are far more ambitious. “The Apollo experiments gave good measurements for just two elements – helium and neon – but we’re going for the whole periodic table,” says Burnett. For instance, they are hoping their slab of silicon will play host to other noble gases, including argon, krypton and radon.

Three of the arrays will bare themselves to the sun only in certain solar weather conditions. Depending on the mood of the sun, the stream of particles that constantly blows outwards from its atmosphere varies in speed from about 300 to 800 kilometres per second. One Genesis array will catch this solar wind when it blows slowly, another will catch the faster particles. A third array will trap particles in so-called coronal mass ejections, giant blobs of ionised gas that the sun burps out a few times each month. While the composition of solar samples from these arrays will vary slightly, scientists say they can work out the exact chemistry of the sun’s outer layers by looking at all three.

Because the solar wind is so thin, the spacecraft has to sunbathe for more than 2 years to collect a useful amount of particles. “We’re talking about just a few ions per cubic centimetre – this is really, really low-density stuff compared to anything on Earth,” says Donald Sweetnam, project manager for the Genesis mission. By April 2004, the arrays will have trapped only about 20 micrograms of solar material other than hydrogen and helium – the weight of a few grains of salt.

That tiny amount could still be enough to revolutionise our view of the sun. To date, our best estimates of the make-up of the sun come from detailed studies of the light it emits and from spacecraft that have analysed the solar wind. In terms of mass, hydrogen and helium make up about 98 per cent of the sun, with other elements making up the rest.

Previous studies of the solar spectrum have identified the fingerprints of over 60 elements. But measuring their abundances isn’t so easy and most elements come with an error of at least 10 per cent. For some, astronomers confess they can’t measure the amounts at all.

Even worse, the solar spectrum says nothing about the various different isotopes of a particular element in the sun. That’s because the light an atom emits or absorbs depends on the energy levels of its electrons – not on the number of neutrons in its nucleus, which is what varies according to the isotope. Spacecraft measurements of isotope ratios often have uncertainties of 40 per cent or more.

With the Genesis sample safely back in the lab, astronomers will be able to analyse it with the most sophisticated equipment to hand. This will improve their measurements of solar elements by a factor of 3, and will also allow them to pin down isotope ratios with errors of just 0.1 per cent, making them tens or hundreds of times more accurate than before.

Having such a precise list of raw ingredients for the solar system might help astronomers understand all the inexplicable differences between elements on Earth, the moon and Mars. For decades researchers believed that the isotope ratios of different elements – such as the ratio of carbon-14 to carbon-12 – are the same everywhere, from the sun to the outer planets. But following the Apollo missions, it became clear that things are not that simple.

Between 1969 and 1972, astronauts on Apollo missions to the moon planted aluminium sheets on sticks into the powdery lunar surface to trap solar-wind particles. Back on Earth, scientists extracted helium, neon and argon from the metal, and found that the ratio of neon-20 to neon-22 was inexplicably 38 per cent higher than in the Earth’s atmosphere.

Even on the moon’s surface, the ratios of different nitrogen isotopes in a rock vary depending on its age. One possible explanation is that the nitrogen content of the solar wind has gradually changed over time, although how the sun could arrange that is a mystery.

The most dramatic variations in isotope mixes are for oxygen. The ratio of oxygen-18 to oxygen-16 is completely different in moon rocks and terrestrial rock, and in meteorites from Mars and the asteroid belt. “As time has gone by, we have found more and more differences, as measurements get more precise,” says Burnett. “There are now a whole string of elements whose isotopes are known to vary in the moon, meteorites and in the Earth, and no one really knows why these variations exist.”

The Genesis sample could help resolve some of these puzzles by filling in gaps in our picture of the sun’s chemical make-up, and how that differs from the make-up of the Earth, Mars and the asteroids. There could be underlying patterns in this “map” that reveal why all these bodies came to be so different. That’s assuming nothing goes badly wrong on the sample’s return to Earth.

In April 2004, the spacecraft will seal the arrays into a capsule and set off on a 5-month return journey. The last leg of the trip will be a detour of about 1.5 million kilometres beyond the Earth, so that the spacecraft can position itself correctly to drop the capsule into the atmosphere above Oregon in daylight. From there it will head south-west across Nevada towards the deserts of Utah, and two parachutes will slow its descent to about 18 kilometres per hour. Fleming’s helicopter will criss-cross its path, and he will aim to catch the capsule by one of the parachutes using a hook and winch attached to the landing skid. Then it will be reeled in and flown back to a hangar. Its final home will be at NASA’s Johnson Space Center in Houston, Texas, which will dispatch solar samples to different labs for analysis.

Sweetnam says the day the Genesis capsule returns will be nerve-racking. “I have great confidence in the flight team’s abilities, but it’s difficult to do and things can go wrong,” he says. “It’s like the reverse of a launch – you have a lot of things happening in a very short period of time.”

One worry is that the capsule’s parachutes might fail to open, in which case it will plummet to the ground and shatter. Or the spacecraft might drop the capsule into the atmosphere on the wrong trajectory. The trajectory needs to be absolutely spot-on for the capsule to land in the right place. “Getting through the dinky little ‘keyhole’ that you have to go through to get to the right spot in Utah is technically difficult,” says Sweetnam.

But the most spectacular task is the mid-air retrieval by helicopter. The US military is well practised in this, having retrieved reconnaissance drones and film canisters from spy satellites as far back as the 1960s. “In the old days, they used round parachutes and enormous helicopters or aeroplanes, and the odds of capture were sometimes as low as 50:50,” says Sweetnam. “With new technology and really good pilots, we’ve managed to make the likelihood virtually certain.”

Fleming agrees, provided there are no unlucky mechanical failures. “Normally, you can count on your car starting when you walk out to the garage in the morning, but there may be that one time that it just doesn’t for some reason,” he laughs. To make sure mechanical failures don’t mess things up, a back-up helicopter and crew will also fly. It will hover at a lower altitude, so that if Fleming misses the Genesis capsule, the back-up helicopter will have a second chance.

Fleming has already practised catching a dummy capsule dropped by a plane, and everything went according to plan. He and the back-up crew will train again in the run-up to the real mid-air retrieval, so that he can be sure everyone will be confident on the day. “By the time it happens, we’re going to have everything worked out.”

Sampling the solar system

The Genesis spacecraft will not be the first to bring extraterrestrial material back to Earth. More than three decades ago, the Soviet Union pioneered robotic sample return with its Luna 16 spacecraft, which touched down on the moon’s Sea of Fertility in 1970.

Luna 16 drilled into the lunar surface and returned a soil sample to Earth. However, the US had already stolen Russia’s thunder – the previous year, Apollo astronauts had hand-picked lunar rocks and brought them home.

Abandoned for decades, robotic sample return is now enjoying a renaissance. As well as the Genesis mission, NASA is bringing back a smidgen of comet dust. Its Stardust spacecraft is on the last leg of its journey to a comet called Wild 2. The spacecraft will fly through the dust cloud surrounding the comet’s nucleus in January next year, capturing some of the particles and bringing them back to Earth in 2006.

The next extraterrestrial souvenir to arrive will be gravel from an asteroid. Launched in May this year, the Japanese spacecraft MUSES-C will reach an asteroid called 1998SF36 in 2005. It will fire bullets at the asteroid, gather a teaspoonful of the ejected fragments, then return them to Australia in 2007.

Despite lots of talk, there are still no concrete plans to retrieve samples from Mars. NASA planned to launch a mission in 2005, but it has now been pushed back to 2014 at the earliest. “There are a lot of technical challenges that push the cost above what is palatable right now,” says Donald Sweetnam, Genesis project manager. “You have to take off from Earth, set down on the Martian surface, take a sample, then lift off from a new environment – that’s a whole new category of difficulty.”

Nonetheless, planetary scientists have a lot to look forward to. With hands-on lab measurements of the chemical make-up of the sun, comet dust and asteroid gravel – not forgetting the much-studied Apollo moon rocks and myriad meteorites that have made their way here uninvited – they will have a much clearer picture of the true chemical diversity of the solar system in the next 5 years.

More from èƵ

Explore the latest news, articles and features