A SMELL of synthesis is in the air, tinged with a whiff of brimstone. As befits these perilous times, palaeontological minds are concentrating on past catastrophes that have devastated life. The luxury of leafing back through the testimony of the rocks is that we can rejoice in the good news all over again: no matter what has been thrown at it, life has survived. The result is a stimulating crop of books from professorial palaeontologists such as Harvard’s Andrew Knoll, Bristol’s Mike Benton and Simon Conway Morris at the University of Cambridge.
The difficult bit of the stories they tell – and the real interest – lie in the small print of the fossils, their evolutionary relationships and their distribution through time. Most importantly, it’s in the interpretation of the data.
The Precambrian lasted a mind-blowing 4 billion years, about 90 per cent of Earth’s history, yet it’s still largely a mystery. Knoll is well placed to tell this amazing story, and he does so with verve in Life on a Young Planet, exploring the long “slow-burning fuse” of those first 3 billion years when life managed to persist despite bombardment from space, widespread volcanism, intense doses of ultraviolet light, runaway glaciation and so on.
Advertisement
As extinctions go, the best known is the Cretaceous-Tertiary boundary event 65 million years ago, when flightless creatures such as dinosaurs died out. But as Mike Benton’s When Life Nearly Died reminds us, by far the biggest mass extinction happened at the end of the Permian 251 million years ago, when 90 per cent of all life perished. Nobody yet knows what happened. Benton expertly reviews the evidence for both students and the general reader. In the race to explain, the front runner remains the outpourings of lava and gas leading to climate change, with gas hydrates coming up fast on the outside lane. Yet everyone still nervously glances skywards: something unexpected from space could pip the favourites at the post.
When it comes to the rise and fall of particular fossil groups, the intriguing extinct flying reptiles are often overlooked. New information, especially from China, has been synthesised by international experts Eric Buffetaut and J. M. Mazin in the Evolution and Palaeobiology of Pterosaurs. National geological “biographies” such as The Geology of Scotland and The Geology of Spain also provide invaluable syntheses. Both include up-to-date reviews of all aspects of the subject, including palaeontology. Both are aimed at students and researchers, but an informed amateur would find them useful, too.
For some years Simon Conway Morris has been setting his cat among the fluffy dinosaurs of science. Among them are the late Stephen Jay Gould and John Maynard Smith, who assert that life’s trajectory is largely accidental, without meaning or purpose and at the mercy of cosmological happenstance, having been blown off course and set back numerous times.
In Life’s Solution, Conway Morris takes as his central theme evolutionary convergence and presents a fascinating, densely argued counter to the scientific nihilists. He concludes that “the number of evolutionary end points is limited” and “what is possible has usually been arrived at multiple times”, while what was impossible “becomes increasingly inevitable”. According to Conway Morris, progress is simply part of our reality, and “the emergence of something like ourselves” is pretty much inevitable.
Booklist
• Life on a Young Planet by Andrew Knoll, Princeton, $29.95/£19.95, ISBN 0691009783
• When Life Nearly Died by Michael Benton, Thames & Hudson, £16.95, ISBN 050005116X
• Evolution and Palaeobiology of Pterosaurs edited by Eric Buffetaut and J. M. Mazin, The Geological Society, due to be published in September, ISBN 1862391432
• The Geology of Scotland edited by Nigel Trewin, The Geological Society, £27.50 pbk, ISBN 1862391262
• The Geology of Spain edited by Wes Gibbons and Teresa Moreno, The Geological Society, £27.50 pbk, ISBN 1862391270
• Life’s Solution by Simon Conway Morris, Cambridge University Press, £20, ISBN 0521827043