快猫短视频

Beauty and the beast

Being ugly can be a good way to attract a mate

BEAUTY really is in the eye of the beholder. Rather than always chasing the
best-looking members of the opposite sex, some animals prefer mates that the
majority find decidedly unattractive.

鈥淯gly individuals can sometimes do better than good-looking ones,鈥 says
evolutionary biologist Rob Brooks of the University of New South Wales in
Sydney. If the same holds true for people, then it may be time to stop worrying
about how closely you adhere to the Hollywood ideal of attractiveness.

Studies of how birds, fish and people choose mates have found that members of
the same species tend to find the same things attractive. For instance, peahens
prefer to mate with brightly coloured, long-tailed peacocks, while women prefer
tall men. Those attractive traits are supposed to signal beneficial
characteristics such as an increased chance that any offspring will survive.

But there are problems with the idea that all animals prefer the same
features. For a start, you would expect birds and fish of the same
species鈥攁nd perhaps people too鈥攖o look far more similar than they
do, because evolutionary forces would have moulded them into a super-attractive
archetype.

What鈥檚 more, most of us know from experience that one person鈥檚 dog is another
person鈥檚 sex god鈥攁nd that makes some evolutionary biologists cautious
about assuming that animals have only one ideal of attractiveness. 鈥淧eople say
鈥業 don鈥檛 like what my mate down the pub likes鈥. How do you reconcile that with a
universal Hollywood idea of attractiveness?鈥 says Brooks.

To find out, he joined forces with John Endler, an ecological geneticist at
James Cook University in Townsville, to observe how individual female guppies
choose between different males. They found that although all the females liked
males with bright orange spots and large tails, a minority of females also liked
males with black markings.

鈥淚t鈥檚 a nice result,鈥 says Raoul Mulder, an evolutionary ecologist at the
University of Melbourne. 鈥淚t explains why certain very rare colour patterns
continue to persist in guppy populations.鈥

Brooks says that previous studies failed to detect idiosyncratic mate choice
because they looked at what whole populations found attractive on average. 鈥淏ut
you don鈥檛 mate with an average, you mate with an individual,鈥 he says. There may
be a good reason that attractiveness is idiosyncratic, Brooks says. What
benefits one individual might not necessarily benefit another.

For example, says Brooks, this may be what happens with immune system
proteins called MHC molecules. The more diverse a selection you inherit from
your parents, the better equipped you are to fight off disease. Men with
different MHCs smell differently, and not only can women detect that difference,
but they also tend to prefer the smell of men whose MHCs complement their own.
This makes sense because any children resulting from such a pairing would have
more diverse MHCs
(快猫短视频, 10 February, p 36).

鈥淢HC is a great example of a real genetic benefit to mate choice that isn鈥檛
uniform,鈥 says Brooks.

  • More at:
    Evolution (vol 55, p 1644)

More from 快猫短视频

Explore the latest news, articles and features