èƵ

Parallel pasts

What will future archaeologists study, asks Nick Saunders

CAN we predict what aspects of today’s consumer-driven and politically
troubled global economy might interest archaeologists as little as 10 years from
now? We can’t be sure, but there are fascinating and disturbing clues in this
bunch of books.

Archaeology is largely the study of past material culture. It has always been
multidisciplinary, embracing geology, anthropology and history, but boundaries
are now blurring as never before to show how our contemporary views of the world
shape the complex nature of the past. Archaeology is a political and a
scientific project, drawing on cultural identity, ethnicity and religion. So
from Stonehenge to Bosnia and beyond, there is no single, stable “past”, only a
multiplicity of possibilities.

Three trends stand out. The first concerns the ever widening remit of
archaeology to add previously unrecognised areas for research. Even
well-established new disciplines such as industrial archaeology appear
inadequate, anchored as they are to mainly pre-20th-century topics. What’s
driving change so forcefully is the realisation that mass industrialisation,
particularly of globalised warfare, has left a unique archaeological record of
the 20th century, such as, the battlefields and souvenirs of the First World
War.

As Dangerous Energy by Wayne Cocroft shows, there are extraordinary
architectural and associated remains of armaments production in Britain. The
palimpsest of landscaped factory sites such as Waltham Abbey in Essex and traces
of the 1930s re-armament programme show an unexpected perspective on the past
century.

As the way in which we look at the recent past changes, new approaches
appear. Take Michael Stratton’s and Barrie Trinder’s Twentieth Century
Industrial Archaeology. Rather than using traditional industrial
archaeology to chart changing forms of airports and shipbuilding, they
concentrate on changes in culture and technology, persuading us to rethink the
civilian legacy of two world wars.

Such boundary-pushing studies fit well with anthropological approaches to
landscape in Contested Landscapes, edited by Barbara Bender and Margot
Winer. They show that human activities shaped landscapes, and these in turn
shape people’s relationships with the material worlds they have created.

A second, equally important development is the identification of new levels of
archaeological inquiry. One of the most promising is explored in The
Archaeology of Communities, edited by Marcello Canuto and Jason Yaeger.
This innovative book explores the yawning gap between two established approaches
to ancient cultures seen either as empires or, more recently, as households.
They dissect this notion of community hitherto seen as an obvious and socially
coherent “given”—Aztec empire or Maya city—and instead use
“household” as a dynamic abstraction to explore and interpret variations in
material culture and social activities.

The third—and most contentious— development involves a
provocative attempt to redefine the nature of archaeology. In Archaeologies
of the Contemporary Past, Victor Buchli and Gavin Lucas see archaeology as
part of a broader anthropological assessment of material culture. Archaeology
becomes a unique way of examining relationships between people and objects of
any time or culture, rather than simply looking at the past. The “archaeology of
us” moves beyond the powerful but limited practice of ethnoarchaeology, which
offers modern ethnographic analogies to throw light on similar prehistoric
practices, so elegantly presented in Ethnoarchaeology in Action by
Nicholas David and Carol Kramer.

By coining the term “contemporary past”, Buchli and Lucas have captured the
moment. They examine the archaeology of present societies. Their case studies of
the archaeologies of a council house, a crashed Second World War bomber and
strike-breaking in the US force us to think in strange and unfamiliar ways, even
to consider the archaeological possibilities of events that haven’t yet taken
place.

  • Dangerous Energy: The archaeology of gunpowder and military explosives manufacture
    by Wayne Cocroft, English Heritage, £45, ISBN1850747180
  • Twentieth Century Industrial Archaeology
    by Michael Stratton and Barrie Trinder, E. & F.N. Spon, £29.99, ISBN 0419246800
  • Contested Landscapes: Movement, exile and place
    edited by Barbara Bender and Margot Winer, Berg, £42.99, ISBN 1859734626
  • The Archaeology of Communities: A New World perspective
    edited by Marcello Andrea Canuto and Jason Yaeger, Routledge, £19.99, ISBN 0415222788
  • Archaeologies of the Contemporary Past
    edited by Victor Buchli and Gavin Lucas, Routledge, £16.99, ISBN 04115232791
  • Ethnoarchaeology in Action
    by Nicholas David and Carol Kramer, Cambridge University Press, £22.95, ISBN 0521667798

More from èƵ

Explore the latest news, articles and features