快猫短视频

The gene in the bottle

IN the pub of the future, ask for another drink and you could be told you
need your head examined. As the publican slips a crown of electrodes over your
temples, he quickly scans your brain waves on the monitor behind the bar. If
you鈥檙e lucky, the characteristic patterns of alcohol dependence are absent, and
you鈥檙e allowed another beer. Anyone who fails the test, however, is legally
obliged to consult the bar鈥檚 in-house genetic counsellor.

A fanciful prospect, of course, but it鈥檚 not all make-believe. Over the past
decade and more, scores of American scientists have been assiduously mapping the
brain waves of alcoholics and their offspring. OK, so nobody has marketed a bar
brainometer (at least not yet) but researchers do claim to have found telltale
electrical patterns that identify those at risk of alcoholism.

What鈥檚 more, those brain waves could be signposts to the big goal: genes that
influence whether someone becomes a 鈥減roblem drinker鈥. One day, the researchers
claim, we鈥檒l be able to scan babies鈥 DNA and determine whether their genetic
inheritance predisposes them to alcoholism. Though that day is probably far off,
geneticists already have some prime suspects in mind, because they have
identified several physical traits that point to an increased risk of
alcoholism.

The brain wave work may aid that search by providing an easily measured clue
to a person鈥檚 risk of alcoholism. Henri Begleiter, a psychiatrist at the
Downstate Medical Center in Brooklyn, part of the State University of New York,
says the best predictor is something snappily called the P3 component of the
event-related brain potential. What鈥檚 that? Well, crudely put, it鈥檚 the third
spike that appears in your brain waves about 300 milliseconds or so after your
sensory system has been surprised by, say, a flash of light. Begleiter and his
colleagues have shown that this P3 spike is lower in alcoholics than in normal
people. And the smaller the spike, the more severe the alcoholism.

P3 deficits turn up not only in the alcoholics themselves but also in many of
their unaffected relatives and in their young offspring. The atypical brain
waves could indicate that these others are at risk of alcoholism in the future,
says Begleiter, who is convinced that the size of an individual鈥檚 P3 spike must
have genetic underpinnings. Even rats that have been bred to voluntarily guzzle
alcohol have a P3 lower than that of their teetotal peers, says Cindy Ehlers, a
geneticist at Scripps Clinic and Research Foundation in San Diego.

Begleiter thinks the P3 spike is an index of how inhibited your central
nervous system is. The higher the spike, the stronger the inhibitory processes
at work in your brain. So having a low P3 spike means that you lack normal
central nervous system inhibition, says Begleiter. In other words, your brain is overexcited.
Drinking alcohol helps calm this churning activity, but relief is only temporary
and gradually requires larger and larger amounts of booze. Physical dependence
can quickly result.

But stunted brain waves are just one of several factors that can predispose
you to alcoholism. For instance, an ability to hold your liquor from an early
age could also put you at higher risk. 鈥淎lcoholics tell me that early on in
their drinking careers they could consume a lot with little effect,鈥 says Marc
Schuckit of the University of California at San Diego.

Almost 20 years ago, these personal testimonies inspired Schuckit to
investigate young drinkers鈥 sensitivity to alcohol. He compared 453 sons of
alcoholics, all in their early 20s, with controls matched for age, sex and
religion. Inviting them into his laboratory for a drink or two, Schuckit
analysed their hormones, brain waves, motor coordination and subjective feelings
afterwards. It turned out that 40 per cent of the sons of alcoholics were
relatively insensitive to alcohol鈥檚 intoxicating effects, compared with only 10
per cent of the sons of non-alcoholics. In other words, they could have drunk
the controls under the table.

Ten years later, Schuckit tracked down all the men in the previous study. Low
response to alcohol at age 20 turned out to roughly double the risk that a man
would become alcoholic by age 30, says Schuckit. He鈥檚 now carrying out the
20-year follow-up, focusing on the original young men鈥檚 offspring, who are now
in their early teens. By screening their DNA, Schuckit hopes to find genes
related to the low response to alcohol, and hence, to being at risk of
alcoholism.

鈥淚t鈥檚 an incredibly exciting time to be in this field,鈥 says Schuckit, who is
both a researcher and a clinician in charge of treatment programmes for
alcoholics. Although a keen gene hunter, he stresses that genes probably account
for only 40 to 60 per cent of the risk of alcoholism. 鈥淣o one is ever
predestined to become alcoholic,鈥 he says. Environmental factors such as peer
pressure and family stability also play important roles. Begleiter puts it even
more bluntly, noting that genes only predispose people toward
alcoholism鈥攖hey don鈥檛 ensure it. 鈥淭here are no genes for alcoholism. None
whatsoever,鈥 he says. All the same, though, genes matter. 鈥淯nderstanding the
genetics will tell us that not everyone is predisposed through the same
biological mechanism, and so hopefully enable us to tailor treatments
appropriately,鈥 says Schuckit.

But novel treatments are certainly years away. 鈥淲e are still at the beginning
of the beginning in finding the genes are involved in alcoholism,鈥 says Kirk
Wilhelmsen, a clinical neurobiologist cum molecular biologist at the University
of California at San Francisco. He works at the Ernest Gallo Institute, funded
in part by Gallo, the world鈥檚 largest wine maker. 鈥淎lcoholism is such a
prevalent disease that it鈥檚 no accident鈥攊t tells us something important
about our biology. If this is indeed an ancient trait, then we can probably find
the genes responsible,鈥 he says. But the search won鈥檛 be quick or easy. 鈥淲e鈥檙e
not talking about a small number of genes with large effects, but a large number
of genes with small effects,鈥 warns Wilhelmsen.

Geneticists in the field wince when they remember the 鈥渇alse starts鈥, such as
the hype surrounding the announcement of a putative alcoholism gene, the
dopamine receptor D2, in the early 1990s. Excited researchers believed they had
made a huge genetic breakthrough, and rushed into print with their findings. But
when other teams looked for D2 receptor mutants in other alcoholic families,
they didn鈥檛 find them. In the end, it appears, the 鈥渁lcoholism gene鈥 was just a
genetic quirk of the original small study population. 鈥淚t鈥檚 like comparing the
DNA of alcoholic Eskimos with a population of non-alcoholic pygmies, and jumping
to the conclusion that any difference you find is the gene for alcoholism,鈥 says
Wilhelmsen.

Today鈥檚 researchers are determined not to make the same mistake. A
ten-year-old 鈥渂ig science鈥 project called COGA鈥攖he Collaboration on the
Genetics of Alcoholism鈥攁ims to search as thoroughly as possible for genes
that influence the risk of becoming an alcoholic.

This huge genome fishing expedition, funded by the US National Institutes of
Health and coordinated by Begleiter, focuses on 鈥渄ensely affected families鈥,
which are most likely to show a genetic predisposition. To count as an alcoholic
in this study, you must have at least three close relatives who are similarly
afflicted.

鈥淚鈥檓 very excited and encouraged with progress to date, but I wouldn鈥檛 say we
are very close to finding individual genes,鈥 cautions molecular geneticist
Howard Edenberg of the University of Indiana at Indianapolis. 鈥淲e鈥檝e got
reasonably good signals pointing to particular regions on chromosomes. But these
regions each contain some 20 million base pairs and as many as 600 genes, the
vast majority of which are of unknown function.鈥

Those regions contain plenty of 鈥渃andidate genes鈥濃攇enes like the
ill-fated dopamine receptor that might logically be expected to interact with a
drug such as alcohol that wreaks havoc in your brain-but scientists still need
to find direct proof.

The trouble is, alcohol does not appear to have a single specific target in
the brain. Instead, it alters many aspects of brain chemistry
(see 鈥淛ane behaving badly鈥).
So all manner of brain messengers may interact with
alcohol molecules to somehow fuel our appetite for drink. For instance, George
Koob at the Scripps Research Institute in La Jolla recently showed that brain
levels of corticotropin releasing factor (CRF), a neurotransmitter associated
with stress responses, shoot up when alcohol-dependent rats are prevented from
drinking. This adds weight to the notion that alcoholics keep drinking at least
in part to stave off acute feelings of tension and distress. What鈥檚 more,
genetic differences in the action of CRF could play a role in an individual鈥檚
susceptibility to alcoholism, Koob suspects.

Jangling nerves

Another messenger molecule that interacts with alcohol, gamma-aminobutyric
acid, acts mostly to inhibit brain activity. Recent research suggests that
alcohol-dependent individuals have fewer receptors for this
neurotransmitter鈥攁gain, perhaps because of some underlying genetic
difference. Fewer receptors mean less inhibition, backing up Begleiter鈥檚 idea
that alcoholics suffer from a hyperactive central nervous system.

A new player has recently joined the scene, a signalling molecule called
neuropeptide Y (NPY). Mice genetically engineered to lack the gene for NPY
voluntarily quaffed almost twice as much alcohol as control mice and could also
hold their drink better in experiments run by Todd Thiele, Richard Palmiter and
their colleagues at the University of Washington in Seattle.

The altered mice could, for instance, stand up faster than normal mice after
being rolled on their backs when drunk. They also recovered more rapidly from a
drinking bout, even though the alcohol level in their blood was initially
similar to those of normal mice. These results echo Schuckit鈥檚 finding that
increased resistance to alcohol is a good predictor of alcoholism in humans. And
in a neat twist, Thiele and his colleagues went on to show that mice genetically
engineered to overproduce NPY were less keen to drink than normal mice and were
quicker to slip into an alcoholic stupor.

It鈥檚 intriguing work, but researchers in the field reckon it鈥檚 far too early
to regard NPY as the answer to alcoholism. No one yet understands what NPY is up
to in the human brain鈥攊t seems to be tied up with everything from eating
and anxiety to pain sensitivity. And because the lack of NPY might conceivably
cause the engineered mice to develop abnormally during fetal life, there鈥檚
always the possibility that their altered alcohol responses are the end result
of defective development, rather than something that starts in adulthood. To
test this, Palmiter is now producing a strain of mice in which the NPY gene can
be turned off later in development. Meanwhile, Thiele is trying to track down
NPY receptors that play a role in the mice鈥檚 drinking preferences.

All in all, there鈥檚 plenty to keep alcohol researchers busy. After a decade
on the case, the COGA initiative is now gearing up for another five years. With
luck, says Edenberg, 鈥渨e鈥檒l track down the genes in that time鈥. After all, says
Ted Reich of Washington University, 鈥渨e now have hot spots on chromosomes and we
have a range of candidate genes鈥.

Who knows, the world鈥檚 biggest alcoholism research team might just be
cracking open the champagne in 2005.

NO one has yet tracked down genes that drive you to drink, but there are
definitely a couple of genes that can slam on the brakes. In fact, these two
anti-drink genes are the only genes proven to influence whether and how much a
person drinks. These genes are much more common among Asian populations, but
they can pop up anywhere.

You鈥檒l know if you鈥檝e got one. Take a drink of alcohol鈥攁nd the blood
rushes to your cheeks and ears. You鈥檝e experienced an 鈥渁lcohol flush reaction鈥.
In severe cases, your face swells up and you feel nauseous, dizzy and
headachy.

All these horrible symptoms result from an unusually rapid build-up of
something called acetaldehyde, as the body鈥檚 enzymes set to work on the alcohol
you鈥檝e ingested. A reactive compound with all sorts of biochemical effects,
acetaldehyde is also a potent vasodilator鈥攁 rush of blood to the bowels is
probably what makes susceptible individuals feel sick.

These anti-alcohol genes can conjure up instant hangovers, generating a
strong incentive to stay on the wagon. Such in-built protective factors could be
as important as the much-discussed risk factors in determining an individual鈥檚
chance of becoming an alcohol abuser, says Ting-Kai Li, a geneticist at Indiana
University in Indianapolis.

Individuals with a mild flushing reaction break down alcohol into
acetaldehyde more quickly than unaffected people because they have an overactive
variant of the enzyme alcohol dehydrogenase. Severe flushing afflicts those with
the gene for a slow-acting version of another enzyme, called aldehyde
dehydrogenase. This enzyme鈥攖he second step in the breakdown of
alcohol鈥攖urns acetaldehyde into acetate, so any sluggishness on its part
quickly leads to an accumulation of noxious acetaldehyde.

One of the most dramatic gene effects on behaviour yet discovered comes from
a variant of the aldehyde dehydrogenase gene known as ALDH2, which may be
present in as many as one out of every two people of Asian descent. If you have
inherited a copy of this gene, 鈥測ou virtually cannot drink鈥, says Li.

Despite this, however, he and his colleagues have just encountered the first
case of an alcoholic with this genetic trait. 鈥淗is drinking behaviour was very
peculiar,鈥 says Li. To cope with his adverse reactions to alcohol, he had to
drink very carefully. In fact, he sipped his tipple. 鈥淏ut if you keep sipping
for 20 hours, as this alcoholic did, you can still consume a fair amount,鈥 says Li.

As Li鈥檚 alcoholic demonstrates, determined individuals can overcome their
genes. One study in the 1970s reported that about 80 per cent of Japanese,
Chinese and Koreans have visible facial flushing and increased blood flow to
their ear lobes after consuming small amounts of alcohol, while only the
occasional European or Native American has a similar reaction. Yet rates of
alcoholism in Korea, for instance, are thought to be similar to those in the US.
Culture thumbs its nose at genes again.

  • Ethyl alcohol is a colourless, flammable liquid used
    to preserve fish World Bank
  • Beer glasses are by far the most common weapon of
    assault in Britain Jonathan Shepherd Surgeon at
    University of Wales College of Medicine and an expert on
    alcohol-related assault
  • The most valuable bottle of wine was sold at auction at Christies, London, in
    December 1985. The buyer paid 拢105 000 for a bottle of 1787 Ch芒teau
    Lafite claret that was engraved with the initials of Thomas Jefferson. Eleven
    months after the sale, while the bottle was being exhibited, lights dried out
    the cork, which slipped into the bottle and spoiled the wine. Guinness 庐 World
    of Records 2000
  • In the US in 1995, alcohol-related costs in areas such as crime, health care,
    policing and losses in industrial productivity amounted to $167
    billion US National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism
  • Troublesome arguments take place in a third of British pubs at least once a
    month and fights break out in 6 per cent of pubs every week. About 5 per cent of
    pub managers are assaulted every month MCM Research, Oxford
  • One in every 122 licensed drivers in the US was arrested for driving under
    the influence of drugs or alcohol in 1997 US Department of Transportation
  • During 1998, nearly a quarter of Australian men and a tenth of Australian
    women drove while under the influence
    Australian Institute of Health and Welfare
  • The strongest alcohol is an Estonian liquor distilled from potatoes between
    the two world wars. It is 98 per cent alcohol Guinness 庐 World of Records 2000

Genetic Prohibition

  • Further reading:
    What is inherited in the predisposition towards alcoholism? A proposed model
    by H. Begleiter and B. Porjesz, Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research,
    vol 23, p 1125 (1999)
  • Ethanol consumption and resistance are inversely related to neuropeptide Y levels
    by Todd Thiele and others, Nature, vol 396, p 366 (1998)

More from 快猫短视频

Explore the latest news, articles and features