




Why do we have different weather in different parts of the world, and at different times of year? The tilt of the spinning Earth, and the distribution of land and sea, are chiefly responsible
CLIMATE change has become a major scientific issue of the 1990s, with growing concern about the prospect of global warming as we move into the 21st century. But what is changing and how? Before we can even begin to answer these questions we need to know how climate works.
Advertisement
The simplest definition of climate is the “average weather” of a region.
Some regions experience much the same temperature throughout the whole year, others have hot summers and cold winters; some regions are likely to experience rainfall in any month, while others tend to have well-defined wet seasons; and so on.
The energy that drives all these weather patterns comes from the Sun, and it is absorbed on Earth mainly in the tropics, near the equator.
Some of the energy is then distributed to higher latitudes by causing the atmosphere and oceans to circulate. These circulation patterns are strongly affected by the geographical distribution of land and sea, the tilt of the Earth, and the way it spins on its axis.
Simple circulation
Earth and Sun
THE EARTH is a roughly spherical planet orbiting the Sun in a roughly elliptical orbit once every year at an average distance of 150 million kilometres. Although the orbit is slightly elliptical, and we are a little closer to the Sun in some months than in others, this is not the cause of seasonal variations in weather. If it were, the entire globe would experience winter at the same time. In fact, the closest approach to the Sun – 147 million kilometres – occurs in the northern hemisphere winter on 3 January.
The farthest distance from the Sun – 153 million kilometres – occurs in the northern hemisphere summer on 3 July.
If our planet were a uniform sphere, spinning with its axis perpendicular to a line joining the centre of the Earth to the centre of the Sun, it would experience a very simple pattern of atmospheric circulation. This idealised pattern is the basis for understanding the actual circulation of the atmosphere. It is driven by the difference in solar heating between the tropics and the poles.
Because the curvature of the Earth makes the planet’s surface slope away from the Sun on either side of the equator, the amount of incoming solar energy falling on a square metre of the Earth’s surface at the equator is spread over a successively larger area at successively greater distances from the equator. So high latitudes are cooler than low latitudes. In exactly the same way, the Sun’s warming effect is less in the early morning and late evening (when its rays strike the ground at a shallow angle) than at noon, when the Sun is high overhead.
Incoming solar energy is chiefly at visible wavelengths, which are not absorbed in the Earth’s atmosphere. When this radiation warms the surface of the Earth, the surface radiates energy in its turn, but at longer wavelengths, chiefly in the infrared. Much of this energy is absorbed in the lower atmosphere, which is warmed as a result – by the so-called “greenhouse effect” (see Inside Science No.13). This initiates convection.
Hot air for cold
Hadley cell
WARM AIR rising near the equator cools and moves outward at high altitudes before descending again in the sub-tropics at around 30 degrees of latitude, on either side of the equator. Winds at low altitudes return air towards the equator to replace the rising air, completing a circulation pattern on either side known as the Hadley cell, named after the 18th century British pioneer of meteorology, George Hadley.
Polewards of the region dominated by Hadley-type circulation, the pattern of atmospheric convection is more complicated, but as a rough guide it can be thought of as two further cells in each hemisphere.
Overall, warm air is transferred polewards, and is replaced by cold air moving towards the equator. Rising air is associated with low pressure at the surface, and produces rain as the rising air cools; descending air is associated with high pressure at the surface, and is dry. Even such a simple picture of atmospheric circulation can explain broad features of climate, such as the warm, wet tropics and the desert regions just outside the tropics. But even on this idealised picture, because of the rotation of the Earth, winds at low altitudes do not blow due north-south.
Each point on the surface of the Earth completes one rotation in 24 hours.
Near the poles, this involves describing a tiny circle at a very slow linear speed. But at the equator it involves a speed of 470 metres per second – and at a latitude of 60 degrees a linear speed of 224 metres per second, always from west to east. Air that originates near the equator, and is carried polewards by convection, carries with it a momentum of the high west-east speed it started out with. And when it returns to the surface, it is moving eastward faster than it should be at that latitude. So the winds blowing polewards from the equatorial region are deflected to the east. This is why the prevailing pattern of weather at the latitude of Britain or New Zealand, for example, brings weather systems from the west.
To a person on the surface of the Earth, it is as if there were a force, known as the Coriolis force, pushing winds from west to east, and increasing the further the winds move from the equator. Like centrifugal force, the effect is perfectly real to anyone in the rotating “frame of reference”; but because it is entirely caused by rotation, the Coriolis force is sometimes called, confusingly, a “fictitious” force.
Similarly, air returning towards the equator at low level is imprinted with the linear speed associated with the rotation at higher latitudes. In effect, these prevailing winds – the trade winds – are being overtaken by the surface of the rotating Earth as they move to lower latitudes, so that instead of blowing at right angles to the equator they blow diagonally to the west.
The equator they blow towards, however, is the meteorological equator, which follows the apparent movement of the Sun north and south of the equator with the seasons. This region, also known as the Inter-tropical convergence zone (ITCZ) is where the northerly and southerly winds meet. The seasonal variations arise because the Earth is tilted at 23.5° out of the perpendicular in its orbit around the Sun. The hemisphere that is tilted towards the Sun is warmed more intensely both because the Sun rises higher in the sky and because the Sun is above the horizon for more than 12 hours each day. In the opposite hemisphere, the noonday Sun is lower on the horizon at corresponding latitudes, and there are more than 12 hours of night. Because the Earth maintains its orientation in space as it orbits the Sun, northern and southern hemispheres each experience summer and winter in turn.
Between latitude 23.5°N (the Tropic of Cancer) and latitude 23.5°S
(the Tropic of Capricorn) the Sun will be directly overhead at noon on at
least one day in the year. Outside the tropics, this never happens. The Sun is
overhead at the Tropic of Cancer at noon on 22-23 June each year, and overhead
at the Tropic of Capricorn on 22-23 December. Halfway between these dates, the
noonday Sun is overhead at the equator, and the whole planet experiences 12
hours of day and 12 hours of night. The atmospheric circulation pattern has to
adjust constantly to the resulting changes in the energy distribution over the
planet. (The major wind belts shift with the migrating ITCZ.)
Further complications to the simple circulation pattern are caused by the
presence of mountains deflecting low level winds. Different ways in which
oceans, land and icecaps respond to the warming influence of the Sun are also
to be accounted for. But the other major influence on climate is the
circulation of the oceans.
All at sea
Gyrating currents
THE GREAT surface ocean currents are generated by the influence of the
prevailing winds, blowing steadily across the sea. Like the atmospheric
circulation, they are influenced by the rotation of the Earth; but unlike the
winds they are completely unable to cross land masses. So the dominant pattern
of surface ocean currents is a roughly circular flow, or gyre, within each of
the great ocean basins. The sweep of these currents is clockwise in the
northern hemisphere and anticlockwise in the south. The main exception to this
pattern is the circumpolar current that flows around Antarctica from west to
east; there is no equivalent current in the northern hemisphere because of the
intervening land masses.
Within the circulation of the gyres, water piles up into a dome, so that in
the Sargasso Sea, for example, sea level is about a metre higher than on the
nearest coast. The effect of the rotation of the Earth is as if there were a
force pushing everything in the ocean basin westward, and this piles water up
on the western edge of ocean basins, so that sea level in the Caribbean, for
example, is slightly higher than on the Pacific side of the Panama Canal. Like
water slopping in a bucket, as the Earth rotates from west to east the water
piles up at the “back” of the ocean basins. This effect squeezes the gyres up
against the western sides of the ocean basins, producing narrow, fast-flowing
currents such as the Gulf Stream. By contrast, the return flow on the eastern
sides of the basins is slower and more diffuse.
The Gulf Stream in particular transports heat northward and then eastward
across the North Atlantic ocean very efficiently. This is why the British
Isles have milder winters than most regions at comparable latitudes, such as
southern Argentina. Other ocean currents are less reliable than the Gulf
Stream. The atmospheric-oceanic circulation over the Pacific basin seems to
be able to exist in either of two states, one with warm surface water in the
west and cold surface water in the east, and one with the pattern reversed. In
either case, the warm region of ocean surface produces a convection pattern
with winds blowing in to the warm region from the other side of the ocean.
These winds push warm surface water in to the warm region, exposing colder
deep water behind them and maintaining the pattern. But, for reasons that are
still not fully understood, from time to time the pattern breaks down and
reverses. This brings pronounced changes to the weather of regions as far
apart as Australia and South America.
The local phenomenon of a warming of the ocean surface near South America
is called El Niño; it is related to an overall pattern of changes, which
occurs roughly every two years, and is called the Southern Oscillation. There
is some evidence that the Southern Oscillation influences weather on a global
scale, including the intensity of the African monsoon.
Into the depths
The oceanic conveyor belt
IN ADDITION to the influence of its surface currents, the ocean influences
climate through its own pattern of convection. Like the atmosphere, the ocean
is warmed at the surface. But whereas the surface of the Earth is at the
bottom of the atmosphere, it is at the top of the ocean. So the water that is
warmed by the Sun in the tropics is already at the top of the ocean, and
cannot rise by convection. Instead, oceanic convection is driven from the
polar regions, where cold, salty water sinks down into the depths and makes
its way towards the equator.
The densest water forms in the region near Antarctica. There, seawater
freezes to form ice at a temperature of around -1.9 degrees Celsius; the ice
is freshwater, so the seawater left behind is more salty and therefore more
dense. It flows down the continental shelf to form a great current known as
the Antarctic Bottom Water. This cold, dense water sweeps around Antarctica at
a depth of about 4 kilometres, and spreads branches out into the deep basins
of the Atlantic, Pacific and Indian Oceans. These deep, cold currents then
link into a network of currents carrying water around the world.
Wallace Broecker, of the Lamont-Doherty Geological Observatory, in New
York, likens the system to an “oceanic conveyor belt”, which at present works
to the benefit of the North Atlantic. The surface currents that bring warm
water to the North Atlantic can be traced all the way back to the Indian and
Pacific Oceans. The water gives up its heat to cold winds blowing across the
North Atlantic from Canada, and sinks, starting the upside down convection of
the deep ocean current systems. The amount of heat it gives up is nearly one
third as much, each year, as the region receives from the Sun; this mainly
benefits Europe, which is downwind of the ocean. Cold, deep currents then
carry the circulation back into the Indian and Pacific Oceans, where the water
rises once more (pushed by the flow behind it) and warms as it begins the long
journey back to the North Atlantic.
The pattern is maintained by salt. Because the conveyor operates in this
way, the North Atlantic is warmer than the North Pacific, so there is
proportionately more evaporation there. The water left behind by the
evaporation has a higher concentration of salt, so it is denser, which
encourages it to sink. The resulting cold, deep flow starts out as the North
Atlantic Deep Water Current, an oceanic “river” that carries a flow of water
twenty times that of all the rivers of the world put together. Eventually, it
carries salt into the Pacific where it is diluted, reducing the density of the
water in the flow.
The whole pattern is self-sustaining. Furthermore, the pattern would be
equally self-stabilising if the conveyor were to run in reverse, warming the
North Pacific instead of the North Atlantic. But if the conveyor belt were to
shut down, the land around the North Atlantic would be cooler by about
6°.
Climatologists have found evidence of sudden “flips” in climate during the
late stages of the most recent Ice Age, which ended about 15 000 years ago.
There were several fluctuations in temperature around the North Atlantic, and
the last cold spell of the Ice Age, known as Younger Dryas, ended 10 720 years
ago. Northern Greenland then recorded a rise in temperature of 7°C, but
the same region also warmed by 4°C during the 1920s.
There is a suggestion – no more than a suggestion, at present – that such
climate flips from one stable state to another may be associated with
reversals of the oceanic conveyor belt, like the Southern Oscillation but on a
much grander scale. And Broecker has expressed concern that such a flip could
happen again, perhaps as a result of human interference with natural climate
systems by adding to the burden of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere.
Keeping cool: Ice Ages
Effects of continental drift
THE THIRD physical feature determining climate now, after the circulation
of the air and sea, is the geography of the globe. Stretching a point
slightly, it is even possible to talk about the “circulation” of the land, as
well as the air and sea, because the geography is not fixed but changes as
continents drift about the surface of the Earth through the effects of plate
tectonics (see Inside Science No.6). The key influence of the land on global
climate today is its role in obstructing the flow of water to the poles.
Throughout most of Earth history, water from the tropics has been able to
penetrate to polar latitudes, keeping even the polar regions free from ice.
But the polar ice cover of the present-day climate is a good reflector of
incoming solar energy. Albedo, a measure of the reflecting power of a surface,
is as much as 80 per cent at the polar icecap as compared with 40 per cent for
the Earth as a whole. Partly because of this, and partly because the ice cover
acts as an insulating lid on the warmer water below, removing the Arctic ice
cap would have a dramatic impact on climate.
Hermann Flohn, working for the International Institute for Applied Systems
Analysis, in Austria, suggests that to melt the Arctic ice it would be
necessary to warm the world by 4°C. This increase in temperature at the
edge of the floating ice cap would make it melt back, exposing more dark water
which could absorb more solar energy and speed the meltback, until all the ice
had gone. The average surface temperature of the air over the Arctic today is
about -34°C. But, says Flohn, removing the ice cover – initially due to a
warming of just 4°C – would increase the temperature of wintertime surface
air over the Arctic to +4°C, a rise of 38°C compared with the
present day.
Ice ages have been rare on Earth during most of its 4.5 billion year
history. Land has only rarely drifted over one or the other of the poles,
cutting off the flow of warm water from the tropics and providing a base on
which falling snow can build up to make ice sheets. Antarctica today provides
the archetypal example of such a rare geographical event. The cooling and
freezing of Antarctica, associated with changes in ocean currents about that
time, began some 40 million years ago, and a large Antarctic icecap had formed
by 15 million years ago.
But it is much more difficult to create the conditions required to freeze
the ocean at the pole, and floating icecaps like that of the Arctic Ocean
today are far more rare than glaciated continents. Even 3 million years ago,
the Arctic Ocean was still free from ice. The “permanent” northern icecap that
seems so natural to us may have appeared as recently as between 3 and 5
million years ago, as the northern continents jockeyed into position around
the polar sea, cutting off the northward flow of warm water.
The pattern of climate that has existed for the past few million years,
with ice at both poles, may never have occurred before. As a result, the Earth
has been in a frozen state, an Ice Epoch, for about three million years.
During that Ice Epoch, the glaciers have repeatedly advanced as full Ice Ages
have developed and retreated slightly during warmer intervals, known as
interglacials. These cyclic variations in climate are linked with regular
changes in the orbital geometry of the Earth, changing the balance of solar
heating between the seasons. In round terms, each Ice Age lasts for about 100
000 years and each interglacial lasts for some 15 000 years. We live in an
interglacial that began about 15 000 years ago.
Climate zones temperate and intemperate
Equatorial weather is always the same – reliably hot and wet. Outside
this region, at latitudes around 20° where the Hadley circulation produces
descending air, the climate is equally predictable – hot and dry. Descending
air gets hot because the pressure increases as it piles onto the surface
below, in much the same way that the air inside a bicycle pump becomes hot
when it is compressed.
Between the dry desert regions and the wet tropical regions, the weather
is less consistent throughout the year, because the latitudes of desert and
tropical rain shift with the seasons. So some regions, such as northwest
India, are dry for much of the year but experience tropical rainfall during
the monsoon season.
Polewards from the hot deserts, the weather pattern is dominated by
westerly winds, which bring rainfall (especially in winter) to regions on the
western sides of continents. This is the “mediterranean” type of climate,
found in the Mediterranean itself, California and parts of Australia. Further
north and south lie the temperate climate zones and the continental climate
regions. Cold, polar weather completes the broad picture at the highest
latitudes.
The temperate zones, between the polar cold and the mediterranean
warmth, experience variations in climate analogous to the variations in the
monsoon regions, with marked variations in temperature.
Further reading
A good basic text is Everyday Meteorology, by A. A. Miller and M. Parry
(Hutchinson, revised edition 1975). For more about ice ages and the influence
of the changing geography of the Earth on its climate, see Children of the
Ice, by John and Mary Gribbin (Basil Blackwell, 1990). Climate is put in its
geophysical context in Chapter 13 of the Hutchinson Encyclopedia of the Earth,
edited by Peter Smith (1985), and climate zones are described in more detail
in The Weather Book, by Ralph Hardy, Peter Wright, John Gribbin and John
Kington (Mermaid Books, 1985).